Water Softerers

Barbie Bubbles

New Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
Location
Wasaga Beach, Ont CANADA
My water here is pretty hard and I have crusty calcium depisits on my tank lid and around my heaters etc. Even around the house like on my shower heads. So I was thinking of having a water softener installed in my house. How will that affect the water quality for my fish? Does this also help to remove lots of other harmful toxins? Also I imagine the water softener filters both the cold and hot water from the hot water tank right? I use a python hose directly from the tap for water changes so I'm wondering if all the water I'm putting in is filtered then???
 
A water softener works via ion exchange. What this means is that the calcium and mahnesium ions in the water -- the ones that leave the limescale -- are exchanged for sodium ions. That is good for people, since sodium is much less likely to leave mineral deposits, and doesn't cause soap to become slick and hard to wash off. This can be bad for fish, since sodium basically is salt. As in sea salt/brackish water. You will need to research your fish and know how they will react to much higher sodium concentrations. For example, if you are keeping Rift Lake cichlids, you are probably fine, as they are quite used to high mineral content including sodium. If you are keeping discus from the mineral-free Amazonia base, they would most likely respond very poorly to increased sodium.

In every house I have seen it, the water softener goes in the line before the hot water heater, so yes, it softens both the hot and cold water. But, the water softener does not perform any other function other than the ion excahnge, taking calcium out and replacing it with magnesium. If there are other things in your water, like copper, the water softener does not affect them in any way. The water softener is not a filter, it only does the ion exchange. If you are looking for a braod filtration system, you should look into something like an RO unit, though those are going to be much more expensive.
 
Thanks, Bignose for the info. Actually I have a community set up right now. Mainly with angels and I'm considering Discus for my new tank. I think I'm really going to researsh an RO system before I go any further. Seems that a water softener is actually more harmful than beneficial but some sales people have recommended to put on both saying it's easier on the RO filter if the water goes thru a softener first. (Saves on the life of the filter membranes or replacement parts) I didn't think this idea would become so complicated...I just want the best water for my fishies!!
 
Hi Barbie,

Be aware that if you employ RO that you will remove everything from your water this is good and bad. You need a certain minimum mineral content in the water to prevent rapid ph fluctuation. In my situation I use well water with virtually non existant mineral content and a low ph (5.4) due to dissolved carbon dioxide. I have had satisfactory results by buffering with crushed oyster shell. I put it in a nylon stocking and hide it under rocks. If you use RO you have to mineralize either like I am doing or with a prepared product. I do not keep Discus but I understand that they like minimally mineralized water.

Scott
 
qpqscott...that's very interesting I've never heard of doing that. What kind of fish do u keep,and how big is your tank? How much RO water do u put in for a waterchange and how often?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top