ur opinion??

amazingbiologirl

New Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2004
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
Location
Louisiana
since ive been reading a lot about this on the forum and on betta pages....whats your opinion on more than one betta in a tank? im challenging my opinion of more than one MALE shouldnt be in the same tank...but ive reading different opinions! so share forum share!!! :D
 
well, why don't you put two males in the same tank and see what happens if you really want to know....i'm betting they get separated sooner than later though.
in the big picture, regardless of whether or not someone has done it successfully before, you have to take into account something called "quality of life". bettas are such fascinating creatures that they demand your respect if you are going to keep them. having two males sharing tank space stesses them out and leaves them succeptable to disease. the only time that they are ever really together is when they are young and still part of the spawn. siblings will of course live together as we who breed them know from our growout tanks. when the males begin to reach maturity though they begin to search out their own space. it's genetically programmed into them to find a space to build their nest and wait for a female to mate with. once they start building nests they will fight all intruders they are physically capable of. if you go to a website called www.siamensis.com and read some of the articles on wild betta "field trips" people have taken, it sometimes takes them all day to find even a few betta nests. it certainly doesn't seem like they are all congregated in one area from reading what has been written. their opinions i hold in high regard by the way, since they are thai people who care more about conserving the dwindling stocks of wildtype than in breeding show worthy halfmoons for profit etc.
 
Or you could get a few hundred gallon tank. Then there should be just about enough room to keep two. :p

Just because some people have louck, it doesn't mean that you will. And like stated before, how do you know that they lived healthy, low-stress lives? If you don't, then they probably didn't. :no:
 
yeah thats my opinion...when i first started learning about bettas the one thing that pretty much everyone told me was to seperate the males...and the females if theres a problem. occasionally putting them by each other(not in the same tank) is ok so they can have occasional company....but the stress factor has to be considered. but recently ive been gettin a lot of people dissagreeing with my opinion.

thanks for the confirmation of my opinion. the stress and help of the betta is far more important than how many you have in a tank....i think! :nod:
 
Ditto to all of you. Couldn't have worded it better myself. If could easily be done, I'm sure tons of people would be doing it as we speak.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top