Undergravel Filter

Starvinmarvin

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Oct 6, 2006
Messages
110
Reaction score
0
Location
Sheffield, UK
I was wondering how good undergravel filters are? you dont need to do cleaning with a gravel cleaner if you have one of these do you? i have seen one on a website for a good price and i am seriously considering getting one.

Please can i have some opinions, thanks.
 
Yes, you do have to clean with a gravel vac if you have an undergravel filter. All the waste is sucked straight down into it. What happens is it collects under the filter plates, and eventually clogs, especially if you don't do a lot of gravel cleaning.

I used to have them years ago but don't anymore. Ten years ago when I started fish keeping they were very popular, but I consider them to have gone out of fashion if I may say! For most of my tanks I use hang on back style filters because I find them easier to clean. Gravel vacuuming still needs to be done every once in a while but not nearly as much since most of the waste gets sucked up into the filter. I change the filter floss while I'm doing a water change and am done with filter maintenance, rather than spending all that time worrying over sucking junk out of every corner of the substrate. Another plus is that the motor on the HOB is much quieter than an air pump for the UGF. I got so sick of the buzzing and vibrating of those air pumps.

That said, I still use UGFs on a couple of my smallest tanks because they came with them. I do have to do more gravel vacuuming with them but because they are so small (2 gallons) it isn't really a big deal. On one of my 2 gallon tanks I've recently put a mechanical filter on just because it is quieter and does a better job.

Just my opinion, but I hope it helps.
 
Under gravel filters have gone out of fashion because there are so many more effective ways to filter the water in your tank these days that don't require stripping down the whole tank to clean! I wouldn't bother with one to be honest, a good internal or external power filter is your best bet for most tanks
 
In one word crap, wouldn't bother with them more trouble then there worth. Small fish can get stuck underneath them, large fish no good they block them up.
 
This kind of filter are best for keeping hygiene in nursery aquarium with small volume. They can easily be installed. Once it has been afloat, you can plant some herbs around it. Plant will release their roots quickly in this environment, because gravel deters various filth and detrimental matter which are very nutritive for all plants.

They are not recommended for bigger aquariums as you can find many better refiners today.
 
The only way to effectivly clean them is to tear the tank down. If you've ever had to do that, you will find that the area under those plates is like a mud puddle, very nasty. I gave away a set of ugf plates for a 55 a few weeks back, old fishroom junk I'll never use.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top