the problem with specific substrates...

Magnum Man

Fish Connoisseur
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
6,461
Reaction score
5,368
Location
Southern MN
so, I typically prefer a mixed browns, natural looking substrate... but I have a few more unique substrates... I have one tank, that I like the look of, that has jet black sand... except when something else gets on the sand... I have 2 pieces of ceramic media that fell out of a planter, and they stand out like a sore thump, against the black sand... I also have a tank, that has white sand, and several pieces of what looks like carbon, are on it... both of these tanks would be a pain to tweezer out the offending pieces... and as much as I like both, I'm temped to stay with the natural mixed tones, of which both of these would blend into, and not stick out so much...
 
You know what would be cool ? It would take some patience to set it up but it would be majorly cool . Black and natural sand with the lighter colored sand making a design . They have a name for that but I can’t think of it . I would make a Starfleet insignia in the middle foreground .
 
You know what would be cool ? It would take some patience to set it up but it would be majorly cool . Black and natural sand with the lighter colored sand making a design . They have a name for that but I can’t think of it . I would make a Starfleet insignia in the middle foreground .
Personally I don't think it would last long as the different sand colors whould just end up blending together. :dunno:
 
I've spent many years try to pick out stray royal blue gravel bits. A rookie mistake from our 1st tanks.

I prefer tan/brown or black substrate but have whitish/ pale tan pool sand in 2 tanks. If I ever feel rich enough, I'd go with Carib Sea Peace River. Very small & rounded gravel in many brown colors. So pretty to me!
 
Personally I don't think it would last long as the different sand colors whould just end up blending together. :dunno:
Yeah , I think you’re right Jay . I thought fish rooting around would spoil it and adding water plus the current from the filter but who knows . You’d have to add the water very slowly and carefully but it would be cool .
 
if that is something really desired, your highlight color / shape, could be glued or resin'd into shape, and laid on top, and the base would fill in around it...
 
Resin's a good idea! I've cut plastic strips to use as gravel dividers and they work well enough but aren't 100% unless you're keeping fish that won't disturb the substrate much. It helps to use a larger size gravel in the areas that are separated.
Color-wise I am sick to death of black. Whenever I'd set up a new tank that was the only thing I didn't have to think about, I'd just grab whatever black gravel was available. It's in my 20L and the bow front, but the latter is going to get a re-do to white once I can move around well enough again.
I put this stuff in my bargain basement 5 gallon AIO: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CWJV3QRV?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_4 Stupidly expensive, almost as much as I paid for the tank. My little 3 gallon has a mix of natural Carib Sea zen garden/gemstone creek.

Call me crazy but I've always kinda wanted to try jade green. It'd look great with neon colored plastic plants and dinosaurs.
 
I have had jet black tank gravel, but unlike @Magnum Man I have always set up so I can get my long ape arms into every corner of the tank. With local white sand, I get cyano, I suspect because of silica. My pool place has brownish filter sand, and my old pool place had dark grey filter sand I really liked the look of. I tried colour alternation, but even before water changes, the fish and filters caused enough movement I got salt and pepper gravel from it, which turned out nice.
I wouldn't do the star trek design as I like red fish, and we know what happened to ensigns with red shirts.

I use 'sand' and 'gravel' for the same thing, really. I can mix finer playground sand with slightly coarser pool filter sand sometimes. It can give a non uniform colour I like. I don't use it with my homemade undergravels, which get pool gravel mixed with a slightly larger chemically inert river gravel.

There are enormous amounts of sand around here, just begging to be rinsed and used. I'd need an off road vehicle to carry it though, and would rinse away half of it. I live in what was the mouth of a wide prehistoric river, and in many places there's a thin layer of topsoil over obvious river bottom, even after all this time. If for some reason you dig 2 meters down, it's sand all the way down to the bedrock. But I've never wanted to own my own aquarium substrate mine, and I can't train the groundhogs.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top