Stocking A New Tank?

MisssMarie

Fish Addict
Joined
Dec 2, 2011
Messages
885
Reaction score
1
Location
US
All i know so far, is that I want to have 2 otocinclus, and 3 ghost shrimp. If you were given a tank with those fish in there, what would you have in your aquarium?? How would you stock, what groups, and why? Thanks!!

Edit: preferably no killifish or bettas because I want to try something new :)
 
So around 60 litres. Right, I would go for a male Dwarf Gourami or Betta with 6 Cardinal Tetra and maybe 6 Pygmy Corydoras if the rest does not look too over crowded.
 
So around 60 litres. Right, I would go for a male Dwarf Gourami or Betta with 6 Cardinal Tetra and maybe 6 Pygmy Corydoras if the rest does not look too over crowded.

i like the gouramis, could i get a pair of them? If so, what else can i get??
 
What is your water hardness and pH? What decor do you plan to have?

Otos do best in groups of 6+ and do be aware that they will starve without extra feeding.
 
So around 60 litres. Right, I would go for a male Dwarf Gourami or Betta with 6 Cardinal Tetra and maybe 6 Pygmy Corydoras if the rest does not look too over crowded.

i like the gouramis, could i get a pair of them? If so, what else can i get??


If you get two, get them at the same time. I got one, waited a week and the got a second. 5 minutes into the new fish getting into my tank, they squared off and my old one got the best of the new one. I had to return it immediately, which caused me some degree of sadness. I wanted the gouramis as my "centerpiece" fish and since they are so small, I figure two would be better than one. :sad: It was not to be.

15 Gallons isn't a lot of space for two of them. I'd stick to only 1. Also I wouldn't go with the cardinals, Id go with neons instead, as they stay smaller. They are susceptible to new set-ups, so give it a bit of time to settle in first.
 
What is your water hardness and pH? What decor do you plan to have?

Otos do best in groups of 6+ and do be aware that they will starve without extra feeding.

My water is pretty hard, I don't remember the exact number off the top of my head :/ my ph is okay though. I'm mainly going to have some rocks and caves for them to hide in, what plants should i get??

I'll be sure to get 6 otocinclus then.

So around 60 litres. Right, I would go for a male Dwarf Gourami or Betta with 6 Cardinal Tetra and maybe 6 Pygmy Corydoras if the rest does not look too over crowded.

i like the gouramis, could i get a pair of them? If so, what else can i get??


If you get two, get them at the same time. I got one, waited a week and the got a second. 5 minutes into the new fish getting into my tank, they squared off and my old one got the best of the new one. I had to return it immediately, which caused me some degree of sadness. I wanted the gouramis as my "centerpiece" fish and since they are so small, I figure two would be better than one. :sad: It was not to be.

15 Gallons isn't a lot of space for two of them. I'd stick to only 1. Also I wouldn't go with the cardinals, Id go with neons instead, as they stay smaller. They are susceptible to new set-ups, so give it a bit of time to settle in first.

I'll be sure to add them together, and i hear they can do well in a 15 gallon, and I find myself quite attached to them already lol


So, here is my current plan:
~6 otocinclus
~3 ghost shrimp
~pair of Neon Dwarf Gourami

What else would be a good fish to add? (if i could still get more?)
Also, what filter would you recommend? I was thinking the Aqueon QuietFlow 55??
 
So, I ran it through aq advisor, to decide what fish i'd like, and here's the combination i came up with, that said i wasn't overstocked. Let me know what you guys think:
- 6 oto
- 3 ghost shrimp
- 2 Dwarf Neon Gourami
- 6 Green Neon Tetra
- 2 Silvertip Tetra
I'd get two of the Tom Mini Internal Filters - that way i could split it up, one on each side (and it's cheaper and i know the filter work well, and if one quits, it hopefully won't mess me over too bad!) Would the silvertip tetras school with the green neon tetra? and does that sound like an okay stocking plan?? Thanks!
 
So, I ran it through aq advisor, to decide what fish i'd like, and here's the combination i came up with, that said i wasn't overstocked. Let me know what you guys think:
- 6 oto
- 3 ghost shrimp
- 2 Dwarf Neon Gourami
- 6 Green Neon Tetra
- 2 Silvertip Tetra
I'd get two of the Tom Mini Internal Filters - that way i could split it up, one on each side (and it's cheaper and i know the filter work well, and if one quits, it hopefully won't mess me over too bad!) Would the silvertip tetras school with the green neon tetra? and does that sound like an okay stocking plan?? Thanks!
scrap the silver tips. They need to be in schools of 6 or more, and they can be aggressive.
 
So, I ran it through aq advisor, to decide what fish i'd like, and here's the combination i came up with, that said i wasn't overstocked. Let me know what you guys think:
- 6 oto
- 3 ghost shrimp
- 2 Dwarf Neon Gourami
- 6 Green Neon Tetra
- 2 Silvertip Tetra
I'd get two of the Tom Mini Internal Filters - that way i could split it up, one on each side (and it's cheaper and i know the filter work well, and if one quits, it hopefully won't mess me over too bad!) Would the silvertip tetras school with the green neon tetra? and does that sound like an okay stocking plan?? Thanks!
scrap the silver tips. They need to be in schools of 6 or more, and they can be aggressive.

I'll definitley scrap them then!

What would be another good tetra or small fish to add then? One that's not so aggressive
 
So, I ran it through aq advisor, to decide what fish i'd like, and here's the combination i came up with, that said i wasn't overstocked. Let me know what you guys think:
- 6 oto
- 3 ghost shrimp
- 2 Dwarf Neon Gourami
- 6 Green Neon Tetra
- 2 Silvertip Tetra
I'd get two of the Tom Mini Internal Filters - that way i could split it up, one on each side (and it's cheaper and i know the filter work well, and if one quits, it hopefully won't mess me over too bad!) Would the silvertip tetras school with the green neon tetra? and does that sound like an okay stocking plan?? Thanks!
scrap the silver tips. They need to be in schools of 6 or more, and they can be aggressive.

I'll definitley scrap them then!

What would be another good tetra or small fish to add then? One that's not so aggressive
If anything, just add more green neon tetras. 6 is the minimum number, but the more the merrier. You'll see better activity and happier fish with bigger schools. It also looks a lot better to have 1 large school rather than a bunch of small ones.
 
I'm also going to have to disagree with getting 2 gouramis. It takes a stroke of luck to get two to get along, regardless of gender. I have never been able to keep a gourami with another gourami, ever, without a lot of fighting leading to death or at least separation, they're almost as bad as bettas, and worse than any cichlids I've ever kept. There are cases of gouramis getting along in tanks, but it takes a lot of careful aquascaping and a good ratio of males and females.

Stick with one, you won't regret it. :good:

With your tank, I'd try for this

1 dwarf gourami, or honey gourami, those ones are less aggressive
~8-10 green neons, think would do
6 otos

Keep in mind otos and neons are somewhat fragile, and you'll need your tank to be well established before adding them.

Gouramis are also prone to territorial aggression, and you'll have to add it last.

So this means a good fishless cycle is in order.

You can read about those in the beginners resource section

Alternatively, try for different fish

1 gourami
6-8 harlequin rasboras
6-8 corydoras

I think this would work too

But if you take this route, sand substrate is your friend, not gravel. You can get any old play sand from a hardware store, give it a good long rinse, wait till the water runs clear when you run your hand through the sand, and your bottom feeders will thank you
 
I'm also going to have to disagree with getting 2 gouramis. It takes a stroke of luck to get two to get along, regardless of gender. I have never been able to keep a gourami with another gourami, ever, without a lot of fighting leading to death or at least separation, they're almost as bad as bettas, and worse than any cichlids I've ever kept. There are cases of gouramis getting along in tanks, but it takes a lot of careful aquascaping and a good ratio of males and females.

Stick with one, you won't regret it. :good:

With your tank, I'd try for this

1 dwarf gourami, or honey gourami, those ones are less aggressive
~8-10 green neons, think would do
6 otos

Keep in mind otos and neons are somewhat fragile, and you'll need your tank to be well established before adding them.

Gouramis are also prone to territorial aggression, and you'll have to add it last.

So this means a good fishless cycle is in order.

You can read about those in the beginners resource section

Alternatively, try for different fish

1 gourami
6-8 harlequin rasboras
6-8 corydoras

I think this would work too

But if you take this route, sand substrate is your friend, not gravel. You can get any old play sand from a hardware store, give it a good long rinse, wait till the water runs clear when you run your hand through the sand, and your bottom feeders will thank you

So, with the oto, should I use sand or gravel?? So, here's my current stocking plan, tell me what you think:
-1 dwarf neon gourami
- 6 oto
- 5 neon green tetra
- 3 ghost shrimp

Is there anything else I can add to the tank??

Edit:
This is a possible stocking i found that i like, what are the negative things with this setup??
-1 dwarf neon gourami
-6 oto
-3 ghost shrimp
-5 neon green tetra
-2 endler
-5 nana rasbora
-5 zebra danio

aq advisor says this places my stocking level at: 89% so how does this plan sound to everyone??
 
I'm also going to have to disagree with getting 2 gouramis. It takes a stroke of luck to get two to get along, regardless of gender. I have never been able to keep a gourami with another gourami, ever, without a lot of fighting leading to death or at least separation, they're almost as bad as bettas, and worse than any cichlids I've ever kept. There are cases of gouramis getting along in tanks, but it takes a lot of careful aquascaping and a good ratio of males and females.

Stick with one, you won't regret it. :good:

With your tank, I'd try for this

1 dwarf gourami, or honey gourami, those ones are less aggressive
~8-10 green neons, think would do
6 otos

Keep in mind otos and neons are somewhat fragile, and you'll need your tank to be well established before adding them.

Gouramis are also prone to territorial aggression, and you'll have to add it last.

So this means a good fishless cycle is in order.

You can read about those in the beginners resource section

Alternatively, try for different fish

1 gourami
6-8 harlequin rasboras
6-8 corydoras

I think this would work too

But if you take this route, sand substrate is your friend, not gravel. You can get any old play sand from a hardware store, give it a good long rinse, wait till the water runs clear when you run your hand through the sand, and your bottom feeders will thank you

So, with the oto, should I use sand or gravel?? So, here's my current stocking plan, tell me what you think:
-1 dwarf neon gourami
- 6 oto
- 5 neon green tetra
- 3 ghost shrimp

Is there anything else I can add to the tank??

Edit:
This is a possible stocking i found that i like, what are the negative things with this setup??
-1 dwarf neon gourami
-6 oto
-3 ghost shrimp
-5 neon green tetra
-2 endler
-5 nana rasbora
-5 zebra danio

aq advisor says this places my stocking level at: 89% so how does this plan sound to everyone??
No to zebra danios. They should be kept in 4 feet tanks, they're very extreme swimmers, it's not good to keep them in smaller tanks.

Otherwise, don't see why not. But like I said before, one large school of fish looks much better than a bunch of smaller ones. I find a bunch of small schools of fish in a small tank to look rather busy and unsettling.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top