Rock Hounds??? would this be a bad rock, to add to a tank...

The August FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Magnum Man

Fish Connoisseur
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
5,636
Reaction score
4,527
Location
Southern MN
I'm in southern Minnesota USA, so there is no guarantee, but unless someone transplanted it, it's likely native to my area... it's grey green in color ( so copper is a worry ), but seems to have "fool's gold" crystals visible on one side... any guesses to what it is, & if it would be a problem to add to an aquarium, that may now, or someday contain shrimp???
IMG_8401.jpeg
IMG_8400.jpeg
IMG_8399.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I'm no rockhound, but I would test that rock. Put it in a container of RO water, which you have measured for hardness. Leave it for a couple of months, and then remeasure. Lots of things can make a rock greenish - copper, other minerals, and I'm told even asbestos. It all depends on where you are.
I constantly find distinctive rocks on the beach across the road, but generally, after a short time in an aquarium, they look alike with a little algae.
 
usually Iron Pyrite, normally stays more gold color, and less brown, we we have a lot of it in our area, so it's not unusual around here, but the rock's color is unusual for this area... I have a TDS meter, so I could give it a soak... it seems pretty hard...
 
I'm guessing those crystals are micah, but hard to tell. I recommend getting a hold of a university geology department and asking them. Those people love to talk about rocks. :) But in the mean time, I wouldn't use it unless I knew for sure what it was.
 
Vinegar will tell you if it will mess up your hardness, but it won't tell you about any other toxins or minerals that might be present. I would especially be worried about copper and iron. Copper will nuke your shrimp, of course, and iron can cause algae blooms. And who knows what else is in there.
 
If it's from a clean area and hasn't been sprayed with anything it should be fine.

If you're worried about copper, do what Gary suggested and put it in a container of distilled water and test the water for copper a couple of weeks later. I doubt there would be enough leaching off the rock to cause problems to inverts in a big tank like yours.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top