I agree both tanks are nice. A nice blackwater tank is gorgeous but so is a clear tank. I really am excited for my new tank I will be hopefully setting up sometime this winter. So gorgeous. I'll be dirting it and log the process of how well it worked for me. I'm tired of having plants die because my "super powerful and beneficial for plants" substrate isn't beneficial at all.
Cough cough. Seachem Flourite. Cough Cough.
I have already dirted 3 tanks and have experimented and they have all grown massive plant stalks. The roots are crazy, and the height is amazing. I just experimented with non show tanks incase I got a massive algae case. No algae.