Molly eggs/abortion.

racinman42

New Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2004
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
ok my molly only had eggs no live fry any reason for this
i bought her already pregnant she is a pot belly molly
i have never had one do this any ideas

carol :(
 
Possibly the stress of being bought and moved around made her abort her pregnancy?

How long have you had her?
 
i've had her about 2 weeks but i put her in the breeder about 4 days ago i don't think she liked it to much and most of the fish seem to be itchy and i added more salt (told to from a fish shop) i did a water change yesterday and i am still having a big nitrate problem can't seem to get it down did a remedy all and didnt like the way the fish acted so i stopped it did water change and added the salt

carol
 
I don't think salt is good for your fish.
Some say it's ok, but only a very little.
She may of aborted because of the salt.
Also you put her in the breeder too early.

It's very hard to tell when thay are going to give birth.

I allways wait till thay have started giving birth before moving them.

And yes I have missed it many times.

But thay breed so often you will see it oneday.
 
i have had 4 different fish shops say they like alot of salt, some say they even use sea salt ? not sure about that one it is suppose to keep their disease down especially the shimmys and the itching hard to tell who is right i am pretty confused

carol
 
Well I am still new at this.
never had mollys but going to get some soon.

But seeing she only had eggs she must of been very early.

I don't know how long thay carry fry after thay have hatched.

If anyone know the answar please reply.

learn things evrey day here :thumbs:
 
OK. I'm not trying to make you look or sound stupid but try this tick list.

1. Check to see if they are really guppies. Guppies are only live breeders and if they abort you would see little dead fish and not eggs. It’s like a human abortion women don’t abort eggs.
2. Calculate the tank size here is an on line calculator Tank Calculator and use it to calculate the amount of salt. (See point 4)
3. If you are talking about a Salt bath this is what you should do.
A bath containing 1% table salt (NaCl) should be prepared instead. Infected fish are placed in the bath for 30 minutes to I hour at which point freshwater is added to the tank in order to reduce the salt concentration to 0.5%. The guppies are left in the second bath for another 4-5 hours. Afterwards, the treated fish are transferred to clean freshwater. This treatment should be repeated every 2-3 days until the fish recover.
4. Aquarium Salt (NaCl) does not change the pH or the hardness of the water.

Adding salt to your water lessens the amount of pathogens in the water, yet it is only slightly effective in treating fish ailments. I.e. it is not good as a preventative medication.

Salt is most effective when the concentration of salt changes. For example if you have an aquarium with little salt in it and you notice signs of stress or disease in your fish then the addition of a teaspoon of salt per 20L of aquarium water would in most cases be an effective treatment. Some marine aquarists do the opposite and give their fish a freshwater bath to treat similar ailments. In this case lowering the concentration of salt as apposed to increasing it (duh).

One theory is that pathogens, such as bacteria and protozoa, are mush simpler life forms that cannot compensate the change in salt concentration, but fish are able to compensate small changes in the concentration of salt. So changing the concentration of salt weakens the pathogens without harming the fish, giving the fish a better chance to recover."

Note:
A few fish do not tolerate aquarium salt such as Corydoras catfish and many live plants do not do well with salt in their water either.

4a but remember that you should change 20% of your water per week and not just the evaporated water. Also make sure the water that you are changing it with has been sat around the house for three days. You should also buy a water conditioner to add to this new water to kill the chlorine and use bio start. This will start the bio action in the water. This should be added to the water 3-4 days before adding it to the tank.

4b if you add just tap water your adults may survive but your fry will get deformed. I know I lost over 50 fry as I was doing this at the beginning thinking tap water was good enough.

5. Don’t use a breeder I have lost lots of fish this way.
5a. get a Fern plant that is really bushy and the fish that is giving birth will hang around it. Once the fish is giving birth moves it or if you are away at that time the little fish will hide in the fern. Also if you have 7 large stones piled up on top of each other the fry will hide in there as the adults can’t get to them.

6. The mother guppy releases a chemical which stops it from feeding for 48hrs once given birth so you fish will be ok until then
 
fozzy_wozzy_woo said:
OK. I'm not trying to make you look or sound stupid
You did not look at the first post.
It a molly
 
ok im stupid but mollies are also live breeders so just change out guppys for mollies.

guppies and mollies are almost the same.
 
I don't think it is like a human abortion? Thats a bit of a ridiculous claim...

You don't see the mollies lining up in the tank to see the molly doctor now do you :D
 
The babies will hatch during the labour, not before. No free swimming babies inside the tummy, they really are inside the eggs. Fish aren't like humans.

But if you didn't saw anything inside the eggs, the pregnancy aborted quite early. Maybe you put too much salt.
 
fozzy_wozzy_woo said:
OK. I'm not trying to make you look or sound stupid but try this tick list.

1. Check to see if it is really a molly. Mollies and Guppies are only live breeders and if they abort you would see little dead fish and not eggs.
This is false information. I have guppies, and if things aren't just right for them, I often get an egg or two in the mix. And yes, I have seen them come out of my guppies, I know what guppies look like, etc.


I have seen this question a couple of times, and as some one with guppies who has watched them give birth multiple times, I can tell you, guppies CAN drop eggs.


I would assume the same is true for all livebearers.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top