Is this true?

bball4life

Fish Crazy
Joined
Dec 22, 2004
Messages
396
Reaction score
0
I just read that if you have a fish that gets fairly large and you keep it in a small tank for a long time their growth will be stunted. I just wanted to know if this was true since I was thinking of getting a black ghost knifefish
 
It is true that fish will grow to the size of the tank. However, their organs still grow to their full size. Imagie taking everything inside your body, and then craming it into the body of a four year old. That is essientially what happens with stunted fish. Stunted fish will also be more disease prone and live shorter lives.

Please don't get fish that are too small for your tank.
 
The organ stunting issue is very debatable, what is true none the less is that stunting causes the fish a slow and painful and death and the fish will always be in bad health and its life expectancy drastically shortened.

If stunting caused no issues or made the fish unhappy i think the majority of us here would have fish too large for our tanks, but as it stands its a very cruel thing to put the fish through.
 
Kathy Jinkings, Aquarium Fish, Collins 2000, has a good quote on this one:

"It is often rumoured that fishes will grow to the size of the tank they are in and then stop. This is absolutely true. The stopping process is also known as death, and the fish will indeed grow no more afterwards."

It is, in fact, quite a complicated subject and poorly understood. One school believes that the body growth will be stunted but the internal organs continue to grow; this is dubious.

More likely, it is believed that some fish can have their growth stunted by sending out special stop-growth hormones if the tank is too small (alternatively not producing enough growth hormones); this may only apply to certain species. It is a well known fact that many species grow much bigger in the wild than in captivity; this could be a reason.

Another reason could be that their bodies do not develop due to lack of exercise and/or appropriate food (think Roumanian orphanages). Stress is also likely to inhibit growth (in your tank and in the orphanages).

Lack of space is also likely to lead to illness, which again may prevent full development.

And many fish take a good many years to reach full growth; if they never survive that long then you won't see them at their full size in the tanks.

If a fish's growth is inhibited due to any of the above factors, then this is clearly not a happy outcome or a success for fishkeeping.

It is also true that some fish do keep growing long after you would have thought the tank would have made it impossible; they end up deformed (think Chinese ladies feet) and eventually dead.

I imagine (hope) your situation is that you wanted to keep your BGK in a little tank at first and then transfer it to more suitable accommodation as it grows; so your main worry would be if there is anything in the growth hormone theory. I'm afraid I don't know and I'm not sure anyone does know. There may be other reasons against it too- but I do not know enough about BGK's.
 
I have 3 Clown Loaches in a 30g but mine are small and I will be transferring them to a larger tank or selling them to someone who does if I cannot give them a proper home in a few years time. Most people advise against it but if you keep to your promise of re-housing your fish once they reach a certain length, then IMO nothing is wrong with it. Reality is sadly most people never do that and they end up with stunted or dead fish.

I had an albino channel cat I did this with. Started in a 10g, went to a 30g and finally a large indoor pond. It sucks to give up the fish if you can't afford to make that next large tank leap but it's better than tormenting the fish with an undersized home.

Try living in a house with walls that are only 4 feet high and the rooms only about 10 feet square is a good analogy. Sure it's fine as a kid, you have plenty of room but as you get older, you get more cramped and will want a bigger room and eventually, an entire house of your own.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top