how tightly can we cover our tanks, without effecting oxygenation???

You folks do understand that an air stone does not help to oxygenate the water by the bubbles releasing air into the water. The bubbles need to be in contact with the water way longer. The Google AI actually gets it right when I asked "how deep must an aquarium be for air bubbles firsing from the bottom to put air into the water before the bubbles reach the surface?"

AI Overview

An aquarium can be any depth because oxygen transfer happens almost entirely at the surface when the bubbles pop and agitate the water, rather than while the bubbles are traveling through the water column. [1, 2]

How Oxygen Actually Gets into the Water
    • Surface Agitation: Rising bubbles lift water to the top, where it mixes with air and absorbs oxygen. [1, 2]

    • Minimal Direct Transfer: Very little oxygen actually diffuses directly from the inside of a rising air bubble into the water, regardless of how deep the tank is. [1]

    • Any Depth Works: Even in a very shallow tank (just a few inches deep), an air stone successfully oxygenates the water by breaking the surface tension. Deeper tanks just require a stronger air pump to push the air against the water pressure.
I think everyone understands that CO2/O2 exchange is increased by surface agitation, not directly by bubbles rising through the water. The original question was whether a tight-fitting top will exclude oxygen from coming into contact with the surface where the exchange takes place. Running an air stone in a tightly covered tank will serve two purposes: First, it will increase surface agitation, but more importantly to the original question, the rising bubbles will replenish the O2 in the air above the surface so it can be dissolved in the water.
 
Last edited:

Most reactions

Back
Top