HELP! my fish tank ammonia is 8ppm!

The June FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Rhys19

Fish Crazy
Joined
Jul 26, 2021
Messages
212
Reaction score
54
Location
Missouri, United States
I just tested my fish tank and my ammonia is 8ppm!!! How can I lower it without buying chemicals? I have live plants.

my ph is also pretty low aswell as nitrates at a semi alarming level

full results below:
PH: 6.8/7.0 - its like crystal clear no tint of yellow or light yellow it's got like a very very very small tint of blue though like very light blue
Ammonia: very dark green Marked at 8.0PPM
Nitrites: 0ppm
Nitrates: 20ppm
 
Alright I do have an ammonia alert I know some people are against them but they do alert me if ammonia is above 0PPM, etc

and when it does show alert, etc I check it with my liquid test kit and this time it was a good thing I did because it was 8PPM. and the ammonia alert is going back down slowly since I did the change so it seemed to of helped will check back tomorrow and see.
 
No, 25% will only have removed a quarter of the ammonia. You need to change as much as you possibly can, re-test and probably change some more.
don't my plants strive on ammonia though? I don't want to let them die with no nutrients though I do have some API leaf zone.

My ammonia has went down not by alot though it did go down to 4 though will do another WC tomorrow (later today) since it's 2am my time
 
Last edited:
Do a 75% wc daily until ammonia is .25 or below. Did you cycle your tank properly? Also do not overfeed your fish. Till you get this sorted, cut back a bit on the amount you feed.
 
There is some serious misinformation here, I'll come to that but first comment on this ammonia of 8 ppm.

This is not at all likely, as the fish would be dead if the ammonia really was that high. However, there is an exception, and that is if the pH is below 7. Ammonia is primarily ammonium in acidic water, and ammonium is basically harmless. However, it should not show above zero, especially with live plants. This begs the question, did you do the ammonia test correctly, or is the test not reliable for some reason? Or is there something causing this we do not know about?

To the misinformation...aquatic plants we have in our aquariums take up ammonia/ammonium as their preferred source of nitrogen. They do not take up nitrates, unless the ammonia/ammonium is insufficient in balance with other nutrients and light intensity. This is because plants must change the nitrate back into ammonium in order to use it, and that takes considerable energy so plants avoid it unless absolutely necessary.

Fast growing plants--and here surface plants are the fastest--can take up a considerable amount of ammonia/ammonium; surface plants are frequently termed "ammonia sinks" for this very reason. Unless the tank is way overstocked, the fish will never produce more ammonia than the plants will remove--again depending upon the numbers of plants and the species. Slow-growers like Java Fern will remove much less ammonia that faster-growing plants. Plants take up the ammonia/ammonium day and night, so it is a continual process.

All plants use the Nitrogen from ammonium—not nitrates—to produce their amino acids and proteins. And plants can store the ammonia/ammonium. I was in a discussion with Tom Barr a few years ago, asking about the limits if any, and he said it would be virtually impossible to add so many fish to a planted tank that the plants could not rapidly deal with the level of ammonia. Again, it depends upon the plant species and numbers, but you are not going to see ammonia in tanks with sufficient fast-growing plants.
 
Just a note that the amount of ammonia a plant can consume depends manly on its growth rate. If the plant isn't growing it may not consume any nitrogen. Also a plant doesn't only need nitrogen, It also need calcium magnesium phosphate sulfur and several others for growth to occur. Overall 14 nutrients excluding light, water, and CO2 are need. If a plant doesn't grow it may die.

This is a good source of information on plant nutrients. The plants it talks about are mainly non aquatic plants. (crop, trees, flowers) but aquatic plants have the same needs.
 
According to the API master test kit it shows 8.0PPM I'm pretty sure I tested right I'll reread the instructions and see if I did but I changed about 75% of my water if not 85%

and my live plants weren't growing so I bought the API Leaf Zone and they started growing I saw a few green leaves pop up over the few days I had put it in.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top