Help / Advise Needed, Dead Puffer

The June FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

nocpan

New Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2005
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
I feel really bad for killing a freshly bought spotted sharpnose puffer. And I don't want it to happen again.

I have a 30 gal aquarium which has been cycling fish free after being well cleaned with fresh water for 1 month, after which I decided to go salt water, so I added proper amount of Instant Ocean Sea Salt got stable SG of 1.021 - 1.022 and was running it for another month 4.5 weeks exactly cause i couldn't find the right puffer. i have 2 aqua clear 300's running on this tank. With one of those $45 heaters which keep temp up to 1 degree, i kept fixed 80 deg F. Nitrate 5 - 10, Ammonia 0, PH 8.2. No reefs, no live plants, just regular rocks and big blue plastic lookalike reef.

I mean it looked like I created perfect condition for this puffer. I bought it(in a marine fish store, which looked like it has quality and healthy fish), waited for the temp to adjust. Released it into the tank. It was camping on the bottom for good hour, then slowly started to swim and look around, meanhile my GF managed to call him/her "Potion" and tell it our whole family history for next 2 hours. Suddenly started swimming closer to the surface then it went beserk, started swimming left and right bouncing off the glass, twisted in some spasms and pretty much died, it was still breathing shallowly for hour or so being taked by the currents created by the filters.

I feel really bad, I hate when one of my fish dies, (I have 2 more aquariums a 10 gal and 55 gal with freshwater fish) and I feel guilty, my gf was sobing for another hour or so.

I don't want this to happen again, what if anything I did wrong?
What should I do so it won't die?
Is there something i missed? I know fresh water well but am new to salt.

One thing the pissed me after wards was after it died I tested the water the puffer came in from the store ( i never pour the store water into my tank) the water had SG of 1.017 - 1.018 and PH of 7.5 I'm afraid that I gave the fish a shock by transfering it to my tank, but it was perfect, the store water was bad! or was it?
 
im not sure exactly but here at some tips. freshwater its easy to just allow them to float and adjust to the temp. in salt i float them, then take 1/4 of cup of water from the bag and dump it out. i replace it with 1/4 cup of water from the tank. i do this over the next 1/2 hour to hour. this allows for the different conditions of the two different waters to be minimized for the fish. its more important with inverts. i would also lower the temp in the tank. 75-78 degrees

and i maybe wrong but i believe that the temp also cause flux's in the salt content. i am not sure maybe somebody can ring in, but i believe its something like the higher the temp the higher or lower the salt should be. i think 1.023 is the norm for a 75 degree tank. i maybe way off base so hopefully someone knows more about this.
 
Er, did you mix the salt in the tank? Because that's a no-no.

Also, your hydrometer may have been off. If you don't rinse them after every use, that can affect the readings in a major way.
 
no I mix it in a 3 gal container, the pour, but I did that long time ago, my water has been fine eversince, i just had to do minimal adjustments.

I just went and bought another puffer, I'm getting him used to the water, 1 shot glass every 15 min poured into original water he came with.

Owner of the store put a big fight that his salt water with specific grav of 1.018 is perfect for non coral aquariums... i'm new to this but i still don't buy it!

Wish me luck
 

Most reactions

Back
Top