Have you experienced a catastrophe or a near catastrophe for your fish or tank

Fishmanic

Gone Fishing
Staff member
Global Moderator ⚒️
Tank of the Month 🏆
Joined
Sep 23, 2013
Messages
13,443
Reaction score
15,315
Location
Northeastern USA
In my 29 gallon tank which houses 4 BN Pleco, a peppered Cory, and a single skirt tetra, I use a marineland 200 filter. Well this morning, I heard the loud whirring sound of the filter which indicates water is not properly being sucked into the impeller area. I went to check it out and noticed the extension tube had fallen off the intake. I also noticed the tail of my Albino BN Pleco sticking out of the short remaining part of the intake. I tried to pull it out, but it scampered deep into the remaining u shaped part of the tube. I thought he would be chopped up by the impeller. I removed the remaining short tube and flushed out the pleco in the sink. I plopped him back into the tank and he was fine. I reassembled the intake tube and things are now back to normal.

Have you experienced a catastrophic or a near catastrophic event for your fish or your tank? Tell us about it.
 
Last edited:
Glad your pleco is ok! I've had a few similar things happen. My favorite (because it has a happy ending) was when my kuhli loaches disappeared. I thought they were long gone until I tore down the tank over a year later, when I found all of them except one, fat and happy, living under the UGF plates...and the remaining one, also fat and happy, inside the canister filter.
 
Wow ! That’s one I’ve never heard before ! Ain’t nobody could top that .
Maybe a juvenile diamond tetra that survived over a month in my canister filter?

The OP's topic was "near" catastrophe. How about total catastrophe? I was trying to rid a group of juvenile discus of gill flukes using praziquantel, the most recommended treatment. Since praziquantel is not soluble in water, numerous reports suggested dissolving it in alcohol. I did so and observed the fish for about two hours before going to bed to make sure there wasn't any unexpected reaction.

I awoke the following day to find my aquarium had turned milky white and all 6 of my (very expensive) discus were dead. I immediately began slogging through all the Internet misinformation to try and find out what happened. I finally came across a report that claimed alcohol was a super food for heterotrophic bacteria. That was apparently the case, as it produced a bacterial bloom so severe it sucked all the oxygen out of the aquarium.

BTW - Praziquantel is all but useless against gill flukes. I tried another treatment on a second batch of discus also infected with gill flukes (I didn't realize it was a common condition even among the most respected breeders) using DMSO. I continued treatment over a period of 6 weeks, doubling the dose every other week. It was totally ineffective. I finally got rid of the flukes using a combination of formalin and malachite green.
 
Over the years I have had a couple of nasty catastrophes.

I accidentally dumped a bucket of bleaching water for dipping plants with algae into my larger can of changing water. I put this water into two tanks. My 50 gal. with 100 amano shrimp in it where I would put algae coverd plants and the shrimp cleaned it in a few hours. The second tank was even worse, it was 20L holding 23 zebra plecos. I had a buyer who ask me for the price to nuy all of them> I was not sure i wanted them all to go to a single buyer and said I needed to think about it over the weekend. All the shrimp an plecos were kelled.

2. I had a breding group of rare wild caught Hypancistrus L173 in a 33 long. They were actively spawning and I did not pay proper attention to the tank. I went to clean it over a weekend and when I sat down on the stool in front of the tank and turned on the light I discovered it had crashed. I had become gross;u over stocked. I lost one of the breeders and then about 75 offspring from under and nch to some over 2 inches. The offspring wold have sold for well over $12,500. Fortunately, the 9 breeder that survived were still able to breed and the offspring were still coming out healthy I repalced the dead on with the largest of the surviving offspring. *sigh*

3. On two occasions I had a heater get stuck full on in a tank. The first was a 40B which held a pair of discus, one of which was wild, about a dozen rummy nose tetras and 5 Hypancistus L450. When I found the tank the discus were dead- one stuck to the intake of an AC300 and the other in the floating plants along with the rummy nose were mush balls. However, the L450s were all hunkered won in caves and alive. They spawned for the first time about 2 weeks later.

The second instance was even worse. I had a breeding group of Hypancistrus L236 (now identified as part of the Hypancistus seideli group) in a 33L. There were a dozen breeders and about 25-30 offspring. All of them were dead. When I discovered this the tank temp was 124F. Fortunately, I had 25 offsprig from earlier spawns in a grow tank and had sent another 27 to Rachel O. aka msjinkzd. She offered to send some back but I said no as I had another 25 offspring in a grow tank from from which I created a new breeding group.

4. I have had 2 or 3 tanks in my bathroom for over 20 years. We have a maid who comes in once a week and cleans the house. I had 21 smaller zebra plecos in a 10 gal. in the bathroom. She must have gotten some of the cleaning chemicals into the tank. I discovered this the next morning and there were 5 dead zebras. I removed them and then did 2 massive (90%) back to back water changes and managed to save the 16 still alive. As a result I began covering the tank with a towel or bathmat as I also had another 10 and a 25 gal, in the bathroom. Since then she knew to cover the tanks if I failed to do so and I have never had another similar issue again. The incident happened about 17 years ago.

I have had 20 full time tanks for 20+ years and fewer before that and am now down to only 12. Plus every summer set up 6-8 tanks from June - late Sept. - early Oct. on our screened terrace. I am surprised I have not had more such problems. Bewteen my planted communities and my plecos breeding tanks and then the added seasonal tanks I would guess I have had at least 2,500 fish pass though
my systems over the 25+ years I have been keeping and breeding fish. So losing about 125 fish works out to 5% or less in the above losses. The problem is from a dollar point of view those losses amounted to over $16,500 in either my cost to acquire them or what they would have sold for had they not died.

At least I learned not to repeat the same mistake so that was the good side of it all, if I can see any good at all in those losses. I began putting heater controllers on many of my tanks as a result of the heater failures.
 
I lost a breeding pair of Heckels to a broken heater, I bought them at around a year old and after pairing off it took almost 4 years before they started spawning. Fortunately I'd just moved their last batch of eggs out but it was hard to lose the parents.
I've had a few close calls but one of the odd ones was when a Pantodon buchholzi jumped out of the tank and landed on the window sill above it. I wouldn't even have known if it weren't for a bluejay pecking at the window trying to get at her. Who knows how long she was baking in the sun but she survived.
 
In my early learning days of fishkeeping, I didn't have a clue how to stock a tank appropriately. I bought about 15 fish to stock my 35 gallon tall hex tank. The store did not ask me the size of the tank but were just more than happy to sell a large quantity of fish. I stocked the tank with a geophagus, 2 clown loaches, 2 Bala Sharks, and whatever else looked appealing to me in my novice days. I didn't consider the size of fish for a small dimension tank.

Well the Bala Shark would often go around in circles along the perimeter of the tank chasing each other. One day I came home from work and I found the two Bala Sharks deceased on the floor. Evidentially, one shark thought there was more room to swim outside of the tank so he knocked off the lid and jumped out. The 2nd Bala Shark evidentially followed the first Bala Shark.....this was not a happy ending.

Eventually I realized the fish I bought were all too large for the tank size and I changed my ways and didn't buy any more unsuited fish for my narrow hex tank.
Live and learn.
 
Last edited:
Many - here are three:
1) In 2017 the bottom on my 40B split and water was streaming out. I quickly grab a 5 gallon pail and started siphoning out water into the pail and putting all the fishes in the pail. This was around 4am - then around 9am i begged a friend to drive me to the pet shop to get a replacement (i did not have a car). I want to say less than 10 gallons got on the floor but that small amount of water did $20,000 worth of damage to the floor.

2) Around 2020 the seam near the bottom of my 29 sprung a leak and water started to come out - it was very slow leak and at first i thought i had dripped a little water when feeding the fishes earlier. When i realized it was a leak i got a couple of 5 gallon pails out of the closet and put the water and fishes in the pail then drained out the rest of the water - cut out the braces for the matten filter - went over to petco and got a new tank - put in the braces - waited 3 days for the silicon to set and set it up. Fishes did fine in the pail with the sponge filter and heater.
3) Just afew weeks ago during the ice storm the power went out for 6 1/2 days. I have a generator that is hooked up to the fish room but on the 6th day the generator stopped working. It said low oil pressure but when i checked the oil (after spending 4 hours driving around looking for oil since most of the places were closed a week after the storm); i realized it wasn't low oil at all - i begged the company to send out someone and they finally found someone to come out (it was suppose to get down to below 10 that night; so i was a bit worried); the guy determined it was a bad sensor and his replacement sensor was bad so he hot wired around the sensor and got the generator working after 7 hours - 5 minutes later the power was restored. The one tank that suffered the most was the gold ram tank which was next to the door - it dropped 8 degrees and a week later my male ram died. Luckily hte discus tank was on the opposite side of the room against a wall that is dug into the hill so it only dropped 1 1/2 degree.
--
I did have a couple of fishes that died - one of my lovely h. eiylos died but the other 7 were fine (or are still fine); most of the dwarf cichild are actually quite robust and can take a little abuse - but domestic rams are extremely sensitive to cold weather and poor water quality. Oh well. That little tetra in terms of dollars was worth 5 rams. Also it was one of my few females which is another issue.
 
I lost a breeding colony of five pearl gouramis--really, really beautiful ones; three females and two males--out of an uncovered ten gallon quarantine tank where they were living for a couple days while I rescaped their 55g home. One night they all decided to go for a walk. I had never seen them try to jump before. Like FM said, live and learn.
 
I had a ammonia spike in my 10g. Took 5 months to get it under control. But it was my WCMM tank so ofc they survived lol. I am talking ammonia at 7 ppm at one point. Do not every ask me why I had it. It is now a really stable tank. This was 2 years ago; this spike could have ruined my enthusiasm for fish, as I only had that 10g setup. I thought about quitting a lot. Glad I did not, have 3 tanks now, all thriving.

Oh and when I spilled a 5g bucket on my carpet, ehhhhh long story 🤣
 

Have you experienced a catastrophe or a near catastrophe for your fish or tank​

Oh yes, for sure... Silicon seal let go and an enormous amount of water came out...! Then the stress shows up whether those fish will be dried or can I save them...?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top