Cycling - Should I Do A Water Change?

SouthernCross

Fish Addict
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Messages
852
Reaction score
0
Location
AU
Hey everyone - this is my first post. :D
I have been reading this forum and others extensively (am now completely hooked - I spend hours on here researching!) and I still have a few questions.
Here is my setup -

New (as of Christmas) 36x14x18 inch glass aquarium (worked that out to be about 148L or around 39 US gallons) with stand and hood. Running an undergravel filter, have lighting, and a heater (although the heater is not turned on - its summer here in Australia and the tank is sitting around 26-27 degrees Celsius all on its own)
The tank has been up and running now for around 3 weeks. It has about 2-3 inches of gravel, a couple of ornaments and 3 plants - one of which is a large cut bunch which is now shooting roots out all over the place (Does this mean its healthy?). I'm hoping to establish a freshwater tropical community tank - species I like include platies, guppies, maybe mollies (not sure about their salt) gouramis, barbs, tetras, small corys/plecos and angels.

In terms of cycling, the LFS advised me to use Stress Zyme (a biological filtration booster) as per the instructions for three weeks - then to come back and see about getting some fish, and I could bring a sample of water to be tested if I wanted to. I asked about ammonia/nitrite/nitrate test kits (I had already done some reading up on the nitrogen cycle so I understood the process the tank is supposed to go through) but the guy said not to worry about it, just to let it run then come back. I'm starting to think this probably wasn't very good advice. They did sell me a Ph test kit however - which is on 7.2-7.4, it says the ideal is 7, but after reading the forums I'm not going to try and mess around with that. :/

Since logic told me bacteria was not going to grow unless it had something to eat (and at this stage I wasn't familiar with adding ammonia as per the fishless cycle) - I transferred a 2-3 inch goldfish I had that had been living in a large bowl for around 2 years into the big tank. I thought the cycling process was maybe going to make him sick but honestly he has never looked happier having all that space! I couldn't stand the thought of putting him back in the bowl so I am going to give him to a friend who has a large goldfish tank when I'm ready to stock. I know now this probably wasn't the greatest way of helping my tank cycle but its done now. Goldfish are pretty grotty so I think he's been producing a fair amount of muck for my bacteria... Obviously I can't provide you guys with any test parameters as the LFS didnt want to sell me a kit (I guess I had beginner stamped all over my face), but hopefully you guys can still help with my questions...

I'm planning to go back to the LFS in the next couple of days since the 3 weeks is now up to see if I can get some tropical fish to put in the tank. Before I go I was wondering whether I should do a water change and vacuum my gravel as I do so or not, as I've read that can reduce your bacteria and disturbing the gravel might mess things up too. The water is clear but when moving an ornament (felt a bit slimy, this is good, means its growing bacteria yes?) I noticed I disturbed a bit of dirty stuff on the bottom. Should I do this before or after getting my new fish, or leave the tank alone for longer? Some more questions -

Am I likely to be even close to fully cycled doing what I've done?

Am I right in thinking that since I've had the goldfish in there I will have to stock slowly since its only used to the bioload of the one goldfish? Unlike fishless cycling where you can fully stock almost immediately? How many fish would you guys recommend initially and how often/how many fish should I continue to add over time? I figured I'd start with something tough like a few platies..

Is the undergravel filter going to cut it on its own or should I get another form of mechanical filtration to help out?

Should I have the heater on anyway even though the water temp is up on its own?

And finally (I know the stocking question gets asked a million times on here) based on the list of fish I'm interested in above (obviously I can't have them all!), what would you guys recommend for a selection? Based on the 1' per gallon rule I'm guessing I can have somewhere around 18 inches of fish?

I know this is a massive post, but I would really appreciate any help you lovely experienced people could offer :)

Thankyou!
 
hi,
wow that was a long post lol,
ok you have had the tank running for 3 weeks with a goldfish,
and under gravel filter, can you get a test kit on line? 3 weeks may not be enough time, until your water test is 0 for ammonia and 0 for nitrite it not classed as cycled, my tank took 6 weeks with fish to cycle, thats why you need to see these test results.
you may add on an extra filter if you wish but the ugf should cope, if the temp stays between 26-27 day and night you should be ok without for now, even if you added one and set it to 26 it would not switch on until needed anyway. before adding the tropicals you may wish to do a 20% water change, and a light vac to remove poop, platy are a good fish to start with, add slowly say up to 4-5 inch of fish a week,
as for fish- barbs may bite guppys tails, angels will eat neons when they are full grown and like you said mollys like some salt so corys and a few others may not be able to go in with this. good luck donna :good:
 
Hey everyone - this is my first post. :D
I have been reading this forum and others extensively (am now completely hooked - I spend hours on here researching!) and I still have a few questions.
Here is my setup -

New (as of Christmas) 36x14x18 inch glass aquarium (worked that out to be about 148L or around 39 US gallons) with stand and hood. Running an undergravel filter, have lighting, and a heater (although the heater is not turned on - its summer here in Australia and the tank is sitting around 26-27 degrees Celsius all on its own)
The tank has been up and running now for around 3 weeks. It has about 2-3 inches of gravel, a couple of ornaments and 3 plants - one of which is a large cut bunch which is now shooting roots out all over the place (Does this mean its healthy?). I'm hoping to establish a freshwater tropical community tank - species I like include platies, guppies, maybe mollies (not sure about their salt) gouramis, barbs, tetras, small corys/plecos and angels.

In terms of cycling, the LFS advised me to use Stress Zyme (a biological filtration booster) as per the instructions for three weeks - then to come back and see about getting some fish, and I could bring a sample of water to be tested if I wanted to. I asked about ammonia/nitrite/nitrate test kits (I had already done some reading up on the nitrogen cycle so I understood the process the tank is supposed to go through) but the guy said not to worry about it, just to let it run then come back. I'm starting to think this probably wasn't very good advice. They did sell me a Ph test kit however - which is on 7.2-7.4, it says the ideal is 7, but after reading the forums I'm not going to try and mess around with that. :/

Since logic told me bacteria was not going to grow unless it had something to eat (and at this stage I wasn't familiar with adding ammonia as per the fishless cycle) - I transferred a 2-3 inch goldfish I had that had been living in a large bowl for around 2 years into the big tank. I thought the cycling process was maybe going to make him sick but honestly he has never looked happier having all that space! I couldn't stand the thought of putting him back in the bowl so I am going to give him to a friend who has a large goldfish tank when I'm ready to stock. I know now this probably wasn't the greatest way of helping my tank cycle but its done now. Goldfish are pretty grotty so I think he's been producing a fair amount of muck for my bacteria... Obviously I can't provide you guys with any test parameters as the LFS didnt want to sell me a kit (I guess I had beginner stamped all over my face), but hopefully you guys can still help with my questions...

I'm planning to go back to the LFS in the next couple of days since the 3 weeks is now up to see if I can get some tropical fish to put in the tank. Before I go I was wondering whether I should do a water change and vacuum my gravel as I do so or not, as I've read that can reduce your bacteria and disturbing the gravel might mess things up too. The water is clear but when moving an ornament (felt a bit slimy, this is good, means its growing bacteria yes?) I noticed I disturbed a bit of dirty stuff on the bottom. Should I do this before or after getting my new fish, or leave the tank alone for longer? Some more questions -

Am I likely to be even close to fully cycled doing what I've done?

Am I right in thinking that since I've had the goldfish in there I will have to stock slowly since its only used to the bioload of the one goldfish? Unlike fishless cycling where you can fully stock almost immediately? How many fish would you guys recommend initially and how often/how many fish should I continue to add over time? I figured I'd start with something tough like a few platies..

Is the undergravel filter going to cut it on its own or should I get another form of mechanical filtration to help out?

Should I have the heater on anyway even though the water temp is up on its own?

And finally (I know the stocking question gets asked a million times on here) based on the list of fish I'm interested in above (obviously I can't have them all!), what would you guys recommend for a selection? Based on the 1' per gallon rule I'm guessing I can have somewhere around 18 inches of fish?

I know this is a massive post, but I would really appreciate any help you lovely experienced people could offer :)

Thankyou!
without parameters we cannot tell you if you tank is cycled your lfs will be able to tell you, i cannot advise on first fish as im nt sure how much you bioload could handle, my advise would be to not run away with yourself and add loads of fish, build them up slowly (my first fish where 5 neons after the cycle[not recommended as the need an established tank]) i always recommend anything other than an undergravel filter because i dont like them, not actually sure about the heater if it has a thermostat on putting it on wouldnt do anything anyway as it would switch off at the right temp if not it will raise the temp,

[e] donna beat me to it :D
 
Thanks for your advice guys!

I've been back to the LFS and now have 6 small tropicals in the tank (mostly platies). They told me not to add any more for another 2-3 weeks. I took my water with me, but my LFS doesn't seem to be very interested in testing the water parameters - they mostly have a 'don't overdo it with fish, take it slowly and it'll be all right' kind of attitude. The next one is very far away so I don't have other options really! All they told me to do was watch my PH but from reading here it seems playing around with that is worse for the fish than leaving it alone and consistent even if not on 7...so I'm going to leave it unless I shouldn't???

Test kits (I'm thinking I really need to get one! Preferably one that comes in complete package) - I'm in Australia, anyone know any good online stores so I don't have overseas postage? I'd have to borrow a credit card so hopefully I'll be able to use the online option...

Finally, with the new fish in there now (and I'm sure the tank wouldn't be fully cycled) how frequently should I be changing the water and how much should I change each time now with the fish? Small amounts (10%?) every day/second day or should I only be doing a bit bigger change weekly? This is my main question, I know I can't judge by water parameters at the moment, but is it possible to do more damage than good changing too frequently? Then again I don't want to leave it too long and let the water get toxic...

So many questions again :blink:

Thankyou
 
I don't understand. The lfs store refuses to sell you a test kit? How do they manage to do that? Just go grab one off the shelf and take it to the register.
 
Yeah, seriously... just go grab a test kit (liquid if you can) and buy it. Don't listen to the employees. PH isn't really something you have to worry about b/c your fish will adapt to whatever your water is at.. You need to be worried about your ammonia, nitrite and nitrate readings and since you haven't had your water tested for these, it's really hard to tell if your tank is done cycling or not.
Get your hands on a test kit ASAP.
Until then I'd be doing water changes every day or every other day... bout 10%. Use dechlorinator on the replacement water. Make sure the temp of the replacement water is about the same or slightly warmer than the water in the tank.. and everything should be ok.

I'm still kinda shocked that the LFS people are NOT selling you something... I would've thought they'd be trying to sell you everything under the sun.
 
Hi again

I called the LFS and another one that is a bit further away - neither of them stock 'master freshwater test kits' only individual tests - for the ammonia nitrite and nitrate tests (the 3 I mostly need) one store quoted me about $35 a test the other ranging from $17-$22 a test depending on which test. I've been doing a it of online searching and found the following kit which seems much better value to me -

http://www.theaquariumshop.com.au/shopexd....Master+Test+Kit

Will this test kit be suitable for my needs? I'm not familiar with what brands are good and what are not - only that liquid is the way to go. If this is a good one (or if someone can make a better recommendation) I'll order one online tonight. In the meantime until it gets here I'll just continue to make 10-20% water changes every 2 days then...

I'd appreciate any test kit advice!
 
Thanks very much for reassuring me :)

It's now on order. I'll post how things are going when I get it :) Looks like it'll be about 5 working days...
 
Tank Update!!!

Ok, my test kit arrived (very promptly actually) and I've done my tests.

My temp is sitting on 26-27 degrees celsius (still with no heater on - that's Australian summer for you)
My PH is around 7.5 - this seems a little high - I'm torn as to whether to bring this down...
Ammonia - Between 0.25 and 0.50
Nitrite - 0
Nitrte - 0

Okay, so now I KNOW my tank is not cycled :( I had expected hoped for at least some sort of nitrate reading though - the tanks been running with t least one fish in it for a month now.
Should I be doing water regular water changes? Or should I be letting the ammonia spike higher before I do to kickstart the cycle further?
I've done two water changes since I've had the tropicals in there - one around 30% before they went in the tank, then a smaller one, around 15% two days later (Wednesday). I've done no other water changes since then, its now Saturday night. The fish all seem ok, super keen for their food and active. There's 3 platies, two bronze catfish and a dwarf flame gourami. These guys have now been in there just short of a week now - I had no plans to get more fish for another two weeks or so based on advice from my LFS, but will take on board anything you guys tell me about how often I should add fish. Been feeding them a small amount twice a day.
For the water changes I've been using dechlorinator - the larger amount recommended for chloramine too as I'm not sure what our tapwater has in it. Could this be killing my bacteria back? Should I use less?

How should I proceed now?

Also - one more question
I just noticed I have algae growing on the back glass wall of the tank :( The tank is NOT in a position to be hit by any direct sunlight - but I've been having the tank light on about 12 hours a day as I have some live plants (3 - one is a large bunch) in there. I've decided to cut the lighting back to 10 hours a day -should I cut it back more or do something else? Should I clean the algae off, or will the catfish take care of it? If I should clean it off, whats the best thing to use?

I know you must get sick of all my massive posts with millions of questions but I really do appreciate any help/advice you guys can offer...
Thankyou again
 
Anybody? :unsure:
I just thought I should try and keep it all in here rather than start new threads all over the place...
 
Here's another update, hopefully might get a response this time... :blink:

Just did my tests again

PH 7.5
Ammonia - Closer to 0.5 this time
Nitrite - 0.5
Nitrate - 0

Ok, so I'm thinking my tank has started cycling again (if it ever had before at all) with the fish.

Unless someone jumps in quickly and tells me otherwise, here's what I think I'm going to do...Also, if ANYONE's reading this, I'm still hoping for some answers to some questions 2 posts above...

A 20-30% water change (since nitrites are toxic to my fish yes?) but I think I'll use the weaker dose of the dechlorinator on the back of the bottle.

I'm not going to buy any more fish until I see some steady nitrate.

In terms of the algae (which is growing more and on the leaves of some of my plants too) I was pondering getting an oto, but since I think they're diatoms from reading on here, I'll see if it clears up on its own in a few weeks before adding another fish, but I am going to clean it off the glass with a magnetic algae scraper I picked up today since it looks so yucky. I'm going to get some more plants soonish (it'll be awhile before I can get to my LFS) to help compete with the algae.

I'll keep adding the weekly recommended dose of Stress Zyme too until it runs out - not sure if that stuff actually does much, but anyway.

Any responses/insight/advice as to whats going on with my tank and if I'm doing the right thing would be much appreciated :)
 
I wouldn't start messing around with the ph. Let it settle, test the ph again then choose your fish to suit the water conditions. I put absolutely nothing in my tank apart from water, plants, fish and occasional liquid fertiliser. If you start altering the ph, bear one thing in mind - what if you run out of conditioner or, for some reason, can't get out for any or the shop runs out?.
 
Alright, newbie question: What should the amonia, nitrite, and nitrate levels be to consider a tank cycled? At what point do you start slowly adding fish, at what point can just consider it safe to add however many (I'm still big on gradual additions regardless though), etc?
 
Alright, newbie question: What should the amonia, nitrite, and nitrate levels be to consider a tank cycled? At what point do you start slowly adding fish, at what point can just consider it safe to add however many (I'm still big on gradual additions regardless though), etc?
JollieMollie: Just to let you know, some people get a bit grumpy when someone else jumps in with other questions on their post. Your is kinda related though but better to be safe than sorry next time and start a new thread. :hi: to TFF by the way. Oh, and a tank is cycled when ammonia and nitrite readings are at 0. You may have low levels (up to 30ppm) of nitrate at this point, but that's perfectly normal, especially in a tank with no live plants. If you are starting a new tank then please fishless cycle following the add & wait method from the link in my sig. This way you can prepare the tank before even adding fish and then fully stock once you fishless cycle has finished.

Southern Cross: You really need to be doing 10 - 20% water changes every other day when cycling with fish. Algae growth and bacterial blooms are also perfectly normal in a cycling tank. You won't really be able to start dealing with them and until you are more fully stocked. Best algae cure is 50% of tank planted with fast growing species. If you want animal algae control then most people go for otos and amano shrimp.

:good:

ps: Save your money. Don't bother with the stress zyme or any other crappy additives apart from plant fertilizer.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top