Ok, where to begin?
In early January I bought a trio of clown loaches and added them to my 29 gallon tank. A couple of weeks later, I noticed that they had ich -- they were covered in white sandy-looking spots. It spread to most of my other fish.
I began treating them with Rid-Ich+, with my carbon filter out, doing partial water changes as suggested by the manufacturer. Long story short, after treating for over two weeks, the Ich killed most of my fish. (This seemed really strange to me, as years ago I had an Ich problem that was treated easily with no fish losses.)
Anyway, of the survivors is a large Austrailian Rainbow fish. He had a bit of Ich which went away, and he lost a few scales. In one spot on the side of him where he lost a scale, there is now a hole. I went through the forums and didn't see anything described quite like it: the area is not red or irritated-looking, it is fish-flesh colored (kind of off white). Partially covering it is some white gelatinous-looking stuff, that kind of looks like tofu or yogurt -- in other words, it's not white and fuzzy, it's congealed. The fish otherwise seems fine -- acting normal, fins are good, front and rear end is fine.
My question: should I just let it be and hope that it'll heal (and perhaps that the stuff I'm describing is kind of like a scab), or should I try to treat it? It doesn't seem to be getting any worse.
My water is in pretty good shape for not using charcoal for the last couple of weeks. Ammonia & Nitrates are both 0. Perhaps it's the daily water changes. I plan tonight to do one more water change and replace the charcoal filter as it's been over 4 days since I've seen any Ich.
Any input would be appreciated.
In early January I bought a trio of clown loaches and added them to my 29 gallon tank. A couple of weeks later, I noticed that they had ich -- they were covered in white sandy-looking spots. It spread to most of my other fish.
I began treating them with Rid-Ich+, with my carbon filter out, doing partial water changes as suggested by the manufacturer. Long story short, after treating for over two weeks, the Ich killed most of my fish. (This seemed really strange to me, as years ago I had an Ich problem that was treated easily with no fish losses.)
Anyway, of the survivors is a large Austrailian Rainbow fish. He had a bit of Ich which went away, and he lost a few scales. In one spot on the side of him where he lost a scale, there is now a hole. I went through the forums and didn't see anything described quite like it: the area is not red or irritated-looking, it is fish-flesh colored (kind of off white). Partially covering it is some white gelatinous-looking stuff, that kind of looks like tofu or yogurt -- in other words, it's not white and fuzzy, it's congealed. The fish otherwise seems fine -- acting normal, fins are good, front and rear end is fine.
My question: should I just let it be and hope that it'll heal (and perhaps that the stuff I'm describing is kind of like a scab), or should I try to treat it? It doesn't seem to be getting any worse.
My water is in pretty good shape for not using charcoal for the last couple of weeks. Ammonia & Nitrates are both 0. Perhaps it's the daily water changes. I plan tonight to do one more water change and replace the charcoal filter as it's been over 4 days since I've seen any Ich.
Any input would be appreciated.