Advice Needed On Nutrafin Co2 Kit

cardinal sinner

Fish Crazy
Joined
Nov 21, 2006
Messages
286
Reaction score
0
Hi all

I have just bought a nutrafin co2 kit. The bloke in my lfs raved on about it so much.The only trouble is when I read the instructions it states that I need 3 units for the size of my tank(50 gal) & that it needs to be in a room with a steady heat of around 20 oc, my room drops to around 17oc at night. Have I wasted my money or should I go out & buy 2 more? :dunno:
 
If you look here:
http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showtopic=164548

You'll see that you can actually make your own yeast mixure up & if you do it this way 1 kit will suit up to a 30G tank.

So yes, 1 is not enough but 2 will be more than enough (no need IMO to get 3).

As for temperature, I'd also say don't worry. Some ppl with CO2 canisters & valves and the such like turn their CO2 off when the lights go out (i.e. at night) so I'd say in your case the lower room temps at night could be seen as an advantage....

Andy

PS
They are good value for money (I got mine new from e-bay for £18 inc del), the one I got 2 days ago is bubbling away like a mad-man :lol:

Forgot to add: My house is set to to a temperature of 19°C
 
Hi all

I have just bought a nutrafin co2 kit. The bloke in my lfs raved on about it so much.The only trouble is when I read the instructions it states that I need 3 units for the size of my tank(50 gal) & that it needs to be in a room with a steady heat of around 20 oc, my room drops to around 17oc at night. Have I wasted my money or should I go out & buy 2 more? :dunno:
Try out your single kit. See if it gets your CO2 where you want it. It probably won't, but you'll know if two or three would be best.
 
Yeah, I also suggest that you try one first and see how's the result first...
I have 2 units in my 2 tanks, they work well in my tanks as both are small tanks. :)
 
As already suggested, go for the DIY yeast mix ... far cheaper and better results !

As for the number of Nutrafin canisters .... well Nutrafin quote that each canister is good for 70Ltrs !
So even 2 will fall short for a 50Gal tank especially if you are aiming for a CO2 level of around 30ppm.

I ran 2 Nutrafin canisters into a 130Ltr tank and managed to get my CO2 to around 25ppm, however as with
all yeast based systems, the CO2 output will fluctuate over time.

For a 50Gal tank I think a pressurised system would be far better ! (probably not what you wanted to hear)
 
Yeah I agree with Mr G, get a pressured kit, it'll prob work out much the same as nutrafin units in the end anyway and the advantage of being able to get stable Co2 input should not be underestimated.

Sam
 
fish_tank.jpgHi guys
Thanks for the input. I am very new to the plant growing bit, but I have kept fish before.What is this pressured co2 thing, but mostly how much does it cost?? is it easy to use etc? sorry for so many questions I am a bit out of my depth here!!!! :no: :no:
Heres my tank at the moment (only just set it up)
 
Cardinal Sinner:

Before you go out and spend your hard earned cash on a pressurised system, be sure that your tank setup justifies the outlay.

Apart from Co2, some of the things you'll need to think about are ........

What type of planted tank do you want ?
Do you want a 'high tech/high light/high fert' (and usually high maintenance)tank, or a lower/medium tech tank. You can have a very nice lower / medium tech planted tank, but your choice of plants will be slightly different...... not worse, just different !
Have a look in this months Practical Fishkeeping Magazine ..... there's a very good article on it :hey:

If you are going for a lower tech planted tank, you probably wont need quite so much CO2, so the Nutrafin kits (or a couple of 2ltr pop bottles) might be enought to give the plants a boost.

How much lighting do you have & how much do you want ?

Usually referred to in Watts Per Gallon (US Gallons). For a high tech tank you'll need over 2WPG, thats over 100w of lighting on your tank !
If you bought your tank with a hood and build in lighting unit .... it's probably less than 2 wpg, so you'd need to make some changes, this can be expensive !

How many plants and what type ?
From your tank pic it looks like most of your plants are attached to bogwood etc - Many of these types of plant will do very will in lower light (the ones in your pic look quite healthy), and there are others that do will grow in lower light, they just tend to grow slower.
Have a look here ( Tropica ) and you'll see the lighting requirements for the plants.

Some types of Hygrophilia polysperma, Anubias and Cryptocoryne are all options

What type of fertilisation will you use ?
Some high tech methods (EI) can require 50% water changes per week .... that's quite a few buckets on a 50gallon tank !

None of the above is intended to make things complicated or put you off .... just to help you make sure you've got a plan for the tank. Hope it helps

Cheers
Al
 
Hello Mr G
Thank you for your input, very informative. I have got 2x40w lighting tubes, 1 which came with the tank & I bought an aquaglow. I have a timer on them for 10hrs a day. I intend to feed then with nutrafin plant food, and just pray that they will grow. My dad used to keep fish about 40yrs ago and he tells me that there was nothing fancy to grow plants in "them days" all he had was a grolux light (it was purple, I just remember)His tank was brilliant I think I will have to wait & see what happans. :good:

ps forgot to add temp in tank is 27oc
 

Most reactions

Back
Top