Sparkling gourami...

3fsh

Fish Addict
Joined
Jun 18, 2004
Messages
728
Reaction score
0
Location
California, U.S.A.
I saw these little cuties at an LFS near me and I was wondering if 1 or 2 would be okay in a 2g tank. It's a completely cycled with a small sponge filter (and heater! constant 78 degree temp) and the tank is also planted to get rid of any Nitrates. I have had a few guppy fry and snails in the tank for a couple of months and all readings look great! What do you think?
 
Well, IMO, yes, one would be fine. Conmsidering people reccomend bettas for 1g's, and sparkling gouramis are smaller, I don't see why not.
 
EDIT: and i just read now that you have it planted, but i still think in such a small tank they will feel vulnerable all the time

from my experience with sparkling gouramis (bought 3 about 3 weeks ago and will be getting another 3 soon) - they are very social but timid fish...they do not like to be displayed in the wide open - they really love plant cover and a place to retreat to when feeling threatened...i don't know for a fact but from what i've seen they do much better in groups and display better colors when in a planted tank with someone to show off to (lfs vs. my tank)...

IMO a 2g is just not fair for them...esp. if there are 2 males you will have aggression issues (although they are nothing like betta males)...they do great in the community tank though!

to sum it up, in theory yes you can but i would stick with the bettas in the small tanks to show off their personalities and get some sparklers for a nice display at the top of a community tank! hope that helps!
 
Okay... so they probably wouldn't be as happy in the 2g as in my 10g. I have 8 dwarf sunset platys in the 10g... would 1 male and 2 females be happy with them? Yes, I know "overstocked" you might say... but the tank is overfiltered and heavily planted so I think it could handle it. :D

*Edit*: Now I have a good excuse to get another betta... :whistle:
 
I actualy don't think bettas should be kept in 1 gallon tanks. At least a 2.5 gallon should be provided. But I know people disagree. Still, if you are willing to skip the betta (or any fish fro that matter), you could heavily plant the 1 gallon and get yourself some cherry shrimp for color or maybe a dwarf frog.

As for the sparklers, a trio in the 10 gallon should be ok but make sure the tank is heavily planted with that many platies in there and do make sure you keep up with water changes.
 
i agree that 3 would be OK in the 10g assuming you keep an eye on the parameters and be prepared to get rid of a couple platies if you have to..
 
I actualy don't think bettas should be kept in 1 gallon tanks. At least a 2.5 gallon should be provided. But I know people disagree. Still, if you are willing to skip the betta (or any fish fro that matter), you could heavily plant the 1 gallon and get yourself some cherry shrimp for color or maybe a dwarf frog.

It's actually a 2g! :D But that's a good suggestion... I've always thought it would be fun to have a dwarf frog. :)
 
I think ADFs like company, so you could get 2 for the 2gal. I have 2 in a 1-gal and they do great. The frogs also like to have a floating plant or 2 they can lay on. THey are really cool critters. I think you'll like them! Post some pix of your tank when you're done getting the sparklers!
 
Methinks the Q's been answered, so I'm not going to bother with a new topic. I'm hijacking :p. The same Q, but honey gourami and 3g tank.
 
im pretty sure all honey gouramis are dwarf gouramis....and i would say the tank is large enough, BUT do not have personal experience with keeping them solitary or in such a small tank - i'm not sure that they would LIKE it...again i would really only recommend bettas and dwarf frogs for anything under 5g
 
Some people consider all gouramies in the colisa genus to be 'dwarf'. However, the dwarf gourami and the honey gourami are completely different species within that genus. The former is colisa lalia. The latter is colisa chuna/sota. The dwarf gourami gets to 2" and isn't particularly hardy. They come in several color morphs including the confusingly-named 'honey' variety. The actual honey gourami gets to about 1.5" and looks much more delicate with a much less 'solid' looking body. These are much hardier than dwarfs and, though they also come in several varieties, most males develop a dark blue-black underside once mature which the dwarf gourami does not. This is probably the species you were reffering to OohFeeshy. A single male honey gourami should be ok in a 3 gallon because it is hardy, small and will set up a small territory from which it won't mind not being able to stray far. Females, on the other hand, are not territorial and like company so it isn't fair to get one of this sex. A dwarf gourami would not be suitable because of their sensitivity to fluctuations of water quality and temp. and their unfortunate susceptibility to disease as a result of stress. They also get slightly larger and produce comparitively more waste.
 
I found the dwarf Gouramis to be hardier, as ive got 2 Blue Dwarf Gouramis, and 4 Honey Gouramis, and ive already lost 1 honey Gourami, found it dead at the bottom of the tank, drifting in the plants.

Just thought id put a word in :D
 
What size tank? That would work in something of at least 20-30 gallons but would be risky in anything less.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top