J4MES Fishaholic Joined Jan 28, 2007 Messages 633 Reaction score 0 Location Heading for a ban. Aug 10, 2007 #1 i collected a couple of rocks from a river yesterday and i did the vinegar test one one of them. it bubbled a little bit. does this mean i can not use it?
i collected a couple of rocks from a river yesterday and i did the vinegar test one one of them. it bubbled a little bit. does this mean i can not use it?
O orange shark Fish Herder Joined Feb 17, 2007 Messages 1,998 Reaction score 0 Location GB Aug 10, 2007 #2 whats the vinegar test?
C Covert Fish Fanatic Joined Sep 25, 2005 Messages 118 Reaction score 0 Location London Aug 10, 2007 #3 You could probably use it, boil it first, but it may increase your pH and hardness
OP OP J4MES Fishaholic Joined Jan 28, 2007 Messages 633 Reaction score 0 Location Heading for a ban. Aug 10, 2007 #4 would that be better for an axolotl? the vinegar test is where you drop a bit of vinegar onto the rock.
would that be better for an axolotl? the vinegar test is where you drop a bit of vinegar onto the rock.
B bubblesburst80 Fishaholic Joined Jul 15, 2007 Messages 583 Reaction score 0 Location manchester Aug 10, 2007 #5 from what ive heard if it fizzes on the vinegar test you cant use it, im noot 100% sure tho so i would wait just incase im wrong xXx
from what ive heard if it fizzes on the vinegar test you cant use it, im noot 100% sure tho so i would wait just incase im wrong xXx
Scotch_Egg Fish Fanatic Joined Jun 28, 2007 Messages 80 Reaction score 0 Location At work! Nottingham, Uk Aug 10, 2007 #6 What kind of rock is it. Personally i would never trust a rock from the stream. Ya know polution and stuff.
What kind of rock is it. Personally i would never trust a rock from the stream. Ya know polution and stuff.
OP OP J4MES Fishaholic Joined Jan 28, 2007 Messages 633 Reaction score 0 Location Heading for a ban. Aug 10, 2007 #7 no idea what rock it is. i collect rocks from rivers and streams all the time lol
backtotropical Retired Mod Retired Moderator ⚒️ Joined Jul 9, 2007 Messages 4,481 Reaction score 4 Aug 10, 2007 #8 I say boil it, let it cool, then do the vinegar test again. If it still fizzes, dont use it.
roseK Fishaholic Joined Jul 30, 2007 Messages 529 Reaction score 0 Location Canada Aug 10, 2007 #9 if it fizzes that means its/has traces of limestone which isnt healthy for fishies