raglanroad

Heiko Bleher reply on BIDKA forum:
"In your second extensive text you refer to the MS on the Rio Negro, and I am again and again amazed about some of the papers publishes. There is and was NEVER a Corydoras julii identified (and much less found) in the Rio Negro system."

What is wrong with posting in an old thread ?
Why not lock all your old threads if you don't want them resurrected ?
There was nothing illicit said, no attack on anyone.
some of the information used, to form opinion, was being debunked, that's all.

Why didn't you ask for supporting evidences, instead locking - after saying this ?
"Why post in a 3+ year old thread just to make a comment that has almost nothing to do with the topic? And Gonzalez, R.J. et al. sure disagree. Do you think that they just made that up when they submitted their peer-reviewed paper to a scientific journal"?

If you intend to play dueling authorities, then I claim Heiko Bleher over your little authority paper.
I personally checked with him ...as I knew it was BUNK.
Wanna see ?

why don't you provide me a source rather than call me names? I have a paper in hand -- from a scientific database -- that clearly indicates the authors' position that C. julii come from Rio Negro. If you cite some sources -- like I did in the thread -- then you can look up the paper I am looking at, and I can look at the data you are looking at and we can both be better informed. Jus...