Will It Fit?

Captain Retardo

Fish Herder
Joined
Feb 25, 2006
Messages
1,131
Reaction score
0
Location
Minnesota, USA
I thought I had chosen my stocking list for my 29 gallon tank (30"x18"x12"):

2 Bolivian Rams
4 Kuhli Loaches
6 Three-Lined Corydoras
3 Cherry Barbs
1 Dwarf Gourami

But then it came to my attention that I had too many bottom dwellers so now I am thinking of a fish to take the place of the 4 Kuhli Loaches (So hard having to take them off the list). Is an Angelfish too much of a stretch? Or 6-8 Harlequin Rasboras? Ideas Please!

Thanks! :good:

BTW- It will be a planted tank with sand substrate.
 
Well the cherry barbs might nip the gouramis tail
 
i had 6 cherry barbs in with 2 dwarf gouramis for a while (2 months). they didnt seem to bother each other, not to say they wouldn't though
 
Maybe replace with more cherry barbs. They enjoy each others company and will add color and interest to the mid level of the tank.
I am also fond of praecox rainbows. I think they would do OK in there but don't have experience with them so its just a guess. However, I don't usually reccommend going with more than one kind of schooling fish since its nicer to just have a larger school, IMO.
 
every fish is there own, just coz it says there peaceful doesnt meen there gonna be (sound like a right meany!)
its a good stocking list that uv got there! the bolivian rams develop a charchter and come out when u look at the tank....well ours do! lol :D
 
Bumpity Bump Bump

Maybe replace with more cherry barbs. They enjoy each others company and will add color and interest to the mid level of the tank.
I am also fond of praecox rainbows. I think they would do OK in there but don't have experience with them so its just a guess. However, I don't usually reccommend going with more than one kind of schooling fish since its nicer to just have a larger school, IMO.

I have heard conflicting reports about this, every person on TFF says that they like large schools, but every Book, Website and other Research Item says that they are not like the other barbs and like to have pairs or trios, you could have more though. I personally trust the books and websites, they all agree.

every fish is there own, just coz it says there peaceful doesnt meen there gonna be (sound like a right meany!)

Well then I shouldn't get any fish at all! There could be an off chance that all of them will be incredibly mean and kill each other! Even though they are normally peaceful! :p
 
Maybe replace with more cherry barbs. They enjoy each others company and will add color and interest to the mid level of the tank.
I am also fond of praecox rainbows. I think they would do OK in there but don't have experience with them so its just a guess. However, I don't usually reccommend going with more than one kind of schooling fish since its nicer to just have a larger school, IMO.

I have heard conflicting reports about this, every person on TFF says that they like large schools, but every Book, Website and other Research Item says that they are not like the other barbs and like to have pairs or trios, you could have more though. I personally trust the books and websites, they all agree.

Thanks for pointing that out. I didn't now that. I don't have cherry barbs myself. I have odessa barbs. I was just thinking barbs=schooling but didn't know cherries were different in that respect.
 
cherry barbs tend to be very docile and stay hidden (they like a well planted tank to hide). they will sit away from the action and try their hardest not to get involved in aggressive struggles. they prefer to be kept single (in smaller tanks) and in pairs or trios (in larger tanks). yuo could get more, but the size of the tank would need to upgrade as well.

as for the stocking list... 29 gallon tank (30"x18"x12"), planted tank with sand substrate

2 Bolivian Rams
4 Kuhli Loaches
6 Three-Lined Corydoras
3 Cherry Barbs
1 Dwarf Gourami

i think you may be ok.

i don't know how rams will deal with a gourami as i hear that both can get a little territorial at times. it may work out though. each fish has a different temperment and personality. mine DG is fine in the tank with platies, cories and guppies. i put my blue ram in with my female betta tank (i know not a good choice, but i didn't know what the aggression would be like between the DG and BR. the blue ram is doing good with the female bettas (no fighting). i don't know about this for sure, but just a guess.

the biggest problem i see may be the cherry barbs and rams fighting over those "densley planted" areas for hiding as they both love those areas. make sure that there are clumps on both sides so both groups can have a territory with a "open water" in the middle. instead of the dwarf gourami and rams, you could put a school of harliquin rasboras in there.

the main thing with fish is that just because it works "now", it doesn't mean that it will later. you have to look at the fact that you have a balance in each strata, fish that tolerate the same conditions, aggressive level balanced and if not hiding places are provided, and most importantly... having a back up plan just in case it doesn't work out.

i beleive that this set up will work, maybe remove either the kuhlis or the cories (whichever you like the most keep). this will balance the bottom strata better.

well good luck
hope i helped

:D
 
cherry barbs tend to be very docile and stay hidden (they like a well planted tank to hide). they will sit away from the action and try their hardest not to get involved in aggressive struggles. they prefer to be kept single (in smaller tanks) and in pairs or trios (in larger tanks). yuo could get more, but the size of the tank would need to upgrade as well.

as for the stocking list... 29 gallon tank (30"x18"x12"), planted tank with sand substrate

2 Bolivian Rams
4 Kuhli Loaches
6 Three-Lined Corydoras
3 Cherry Barbs
1 Dwarf Gourami

i think you may be ok.

i don't know how rams will deal with a gourami as i hear that both can get a little territorial at times. it may work out though. each fish has a different temperment and personality. mine DG is fine in the tank with platies, cories and guppies. i put my blue ram in with my female betta tank (i know not a good choice, but i didn't know what the aggression would be like between the DG and BR. the blue ram is doing good with the female bettas (no fighting). i don't know about this for sure, but just a guess.

the biggest problem i see may be the cherry barbs and rams fighting over those "densley planted" areas for hiding as they both love those areas. make sure that there are clumps on both sides so both groups can have a territory with a "open water" in the middle. instead of the dwarf gourami and rams, you could put a school of harliquin rasboras in there.

the main thing with fish is that just because it works "now", it doesn't mean that it will later. you have to look at the fact that you have a balance in each strata, fish that tolerate the same conditions, aggressive level balanced and if not hiding places are provided, and most importantly... having a back up plan just in case it doesn't work out.

i beleive that this set up will work, maybe remove either the kuhlis or the cories (whichever you like the most keep). this will balance the bottom strata better.

well good luck
hope i helped

I have chosen to take out the Kuhlis (Hard to say that, I like them so much! (but i like the corys and rams better...)) And i am wondering whether I should get an Angelfish? (Too big???) or 6-8 Harlequin Rasboras???
 
I would definately go the with the rasboras. They'll add a nice color to your tank, and they may even work as a dither fish drawing out your cherry barbs. As unpredictable as cichlids are, you may run into problems with a rougue angelfish. Just my 2 cents.
 
i would say to remove the dwarf gourami and put in a nice school of harlequin rasboras. an angel fish will get too big and they do better in pairs so this would make stocking all the more difficult.
 
Do you think i should get 2 dwarf gouramis? I have read that they like pairs...

do you think 8 harlequins is good? Too much? Too little?

I am terrible at calculating stocking!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top