Total Nightmare

cane76

Fish Aficionado
Joined
Nov 4, 2005
Messages
3,726
Reaction score
5
Location
middx heathrow
after cleaning my big tank yesterday i forgot to turn the airstone back on and this morning i have lost my tiger fish and my fire eel and 1 needle fish i cant believe it :( i didnt think airstones made a lot of difference
 
Oo Wow, neither did I. I mean, I knew they helped, but my airstone has been off for 2 days (the aerator broke, I haven't the money to replace it atm), and no one has died.

Was your tank highly stocked? I'm just curious. I'm thinking maybe my fish haven't keeled over, because I have 2 filters on it and the resulting current probably 'aerates' it for me (you know, the whole "more surface area = more oxygen transfer" gig).


Sorry to hear about your loss. :/
 
i have the standard jewel filter which i think is sh**.im gonna cut it out and get an external
 
How big is the tank? Like everyone else, I would not think that it would make much of a difference in a larger tank.

Perhaps there is something else which may have contributed to their deaths?
 
I have to say that it is highly unlikely that not switching the airstone on was the primary cause of your losses, in modern aquaria with power filters air stones are completely unessesary except for in extreem circumstances; ie. during a heatwave when high temperatures reduce oxygen capacity or when medicating. None of my systems have airstones and all contain large/predatory fish many of which have high oxygen demands.

Unless there is a more obvious cause such as forgetting to add dechlorinator the most likely cause is that something in the tank is using up the available oxygen and depriving the fish, rotting food trapped in the substrate or filter is the most likely cause, juwel filters are infamous for trapping decomposing gunk in the bi pass chamber inside the filter housing, stick a syphon down inside the chamber and see how much crap comes out.
Your decision to remove the juwel filter could well be the best you have ever made, i have long been preaching about the inadequacies of these filters for anything above planted community tanks with small fish.
 
i have just taken out all the decor in the tank and there was a lot of dead shrimp and rubbish under the rockery.maybe this contributed :/ that and the airstone maybe.im keepin the tank bare from now on just plants and sand.what a morning.oh and the tank is 100g.im gonna go do some water tests
 
Decomposing organic matter uses a lot of oxygen so it is almost certain that this contributed to the demise of your fish.

To avoid this problem i use pieces of bogwood which are arched so that any debrie can be easily seen or place decore directly onto the base of the tank and then add the substrate around it so that it is impossible for anything to get bellow the decore.
 
a few years ago in a 3 foot tank i had, my mum turned off the airstone, i know my tank was way over stocked back then, but it killed alot of fish off :( but now i know more i don't over stock my tanks and now trying to understock tanks.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top