Tank Upgrade - Multiple Fish Death & More Sick

FishForums.net Pet of the Month
🐶 POTM Poll is Open! 🦎 Click here to Vote! 🐰

DBlauv80

New Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Location
Tennessee
Help! We upgraded from a 33 gallon to a 75 gallon freshwater tank on January 14th and have had multiple fish die since then and 3 more are currently sick. We got the tank from a lady who was giving away her tank and asked that we take and care for her fish. She had GloFish tetras, which she said she had for 3 years, and a Chinese algae eater that she had for 2 years. Her fish all appeared healthy and active and her tank water tested well, but we only saved enough of her water to transport her fish. Our fish were healthy before the tank upgrade. I did not quarantine her fish prior to introducing them to my fish, which I know now was a huge mistake. I put nearly all of our water from our 33 gallon tank into the new tank and we did not drain our Fluval FX4 or clean its media so that the bacteria would get into the new tank. I also added some QuickStart since we had a little less than half the amount of tank water needed for the 75 gallon.

Since the tank upgrade, 2 of 3 of our Corys died (I did not observe any unusual symtpoms in them prior to death), our Angelfish died (acted oddly, stopped eating and I think was flashing as it appeared he had rubbed some areas of scales of prior to death, but no white spots that I could see), our Guorami died (looked bloated before death), and one of the prior owner's GloFish died (appeared to have swim bladder problems prior to death). Currently, one of her GloFish has a single large white spot that has evolved into a blister looking bump (this has been going on for a few days), just this morning I saw that one of the other GloFish has a red ulcer over its gills on one side, and my rainbow shark is barely moving and hiding in the corner hanging vertically behind the heater (he is moving just enough to let me know that he is still alive).

I have carefully monitored the water since the upgrade. My ammonia meter says ammonia is at a safe level and has been that way since the tank upgrade. I have done a total of three water changes since the upgrade 2 weeks ago. The first two were about 30% water changes and this past Friday I did close to 50% water change. Nitrates are currently 20 ppm and the highest I have seen them get since the change was 40 ppm (right before the water change). I put in a half-dose of API Ich medicine on Saturday evening due to my concern that the weird white spot/blister on the GloFish is ich; I did a half-dose because I have scaleless fish. The second dose is due tonight, but I am not sure if I should give it since all the fish seem to have different symptoms.

Tank size: 75 gallons
tank age: see above
pH: looks like 7.0
ammonia: "safe" Per meter
nitrite: 0
nitrate: 20 ppm
kH: will need to check and update
gH: usually comes out right in the middle of the test strip (will need to recheck for specific number)
tank temp: 80 degrees

Chemical Additives or Media in your tank: Sand substrate, 1 piece of drift wood, couple of decorations, and a few fake aquarium plants. We use StressCoat+ with water changes and I added a half-dose of API ich on Saturday.

Tank inhabitants: 5 GloFish tetras, 2 plecos, 1 chinese algae eater, 1 shovelnose catfish, 1 black knifefish, 1 rainbow shark

Recent additions to your tank (living or decoration): Just the merging of the two fish communities as mentioned above.

Exposure to chemicals: None, except ich treatment.

I want our poor fish to stop being sick and dying, but I can't pinpoint what the problem is. Please share your thoughts.
437359A1-8B48-45EC-9B71-E2BCFB49C4C9.jpeg
A83B866E-0EE4-4CB6-95EE-8117592A46D1.jpeg
F0B6D14F-53AC-4E52-8BC7-4A12D662E385.jpeg
D8C51938-096F-41B3-9B48-9DEC68828228.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I don't know if I would keep a rainbow shark with bottom feeders like corys. And the Chinese algae eaters become aggressive.
 
Welcome to TFF

Get one of these ASAP, we need to know actual water parameters: https://apifishcare.com/product/freshwater-master-test-kit

Stop using the Stress Coat, it contains aloe vera, which is harmful to fish...get either API Tap Water conditioner, or Seachem Prime

The Chinese Algae Eater could be responsible for the deaths of the angel fish, gourami, and the Glofish, as well as the cory catfish; they attach themselves to other fish, and actually consume the protective mucous layer of the host fish, causing much harm:

"Other bottom-dwelling fishes including cichlids and most catfishes are best avoided as they may be picked on it may even attach itself to the flanks of larger tankmates in order to feed on their body mucus."
Source: https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/gyrinocheilus-aymonieri

Get rid of the CAE as soon as possible, rehome it or donate to an LFS

The BKG has no scales, so it is in danger, as well...and can grow up to 20" in length, needing a much larger tank than what you have: https://www.aquariumsource.com/black-ghost-knife-fish/

I would rehome the CAE, the BKG, and the "shark", ASAP...see "Behavior & Compatibility" here for the shark: https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/epalzeorhynchos-frenatum

What is the hardness of your source water?
 
Last edited:
Welcome to TFF

Get one of these ASAP, we need to know actual water parameters: https://apifishcare.com/product/freshwater-master-test-kit

Stop using the Stress Coat, it contains aloe vera, which is harmful to fish...get either API Tap Water conditioner, or Seachem Prime

The Chinese Algae Eater could be responsible for the deaths of the angel fish, gourami, and the Glofish, as well as the cory catfish; they attach themselves to other fish, and actually consume the protective mucous layer of the host fish, causing much harm:

"Other bottom-dwelling fishes including cichlids and most catfishes are best avoided as they may be picked on it may even attach itself to the flanks of larger tankmates in order to feed on their body mucus."
Source: https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/gyrinocheilus-aymonieri

Get rid of the CAE as soon as possible, rehome it or donate to an LFS

The BKG has no scales, so it is in danger, as well...and can grow up to 20" in length, needing a much larger tank than what you have: https://www.aquariumsource.com/black-ghost-knife-fish/

I would rehome the CAE, the BKG, and the "shark", ASAP...see "Behavior & Compatibility" here for the shark: https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/epalzeorhynchos-frenatum

What is the hardness of your source water?
Thanks for your response. Water hardness in my area is 90 ppm in my area. I had no idea about the algae eater, I will look into rehoming him. Frustrating about the knifefish, I specifically told them that I had a 75 gallon tank when I purchased it, but I know they will let me return him to them in exchange for a credit. I will order that test kit asap.
 
Thanks for your response. Water hardness in my area is 90 ppm in my area. I had no idea about the algae eater, I will look into rehoming him. Frustrating about the knifefish, I specifically told them that I had a 75 gallon tank when I purchased it, but I know they will let me return him to them in exchange for a credit. I will order that test kit asap.
You can't trust fish store employees. We've all had to learn that. Sometimes they mean well but don't know better. And sometimes, they are giving bad info because they just want to make a sale.
 
First rule in fishkeeping: Never trust the advice of pet shop employees; the majority of the time, they are clueless when it comes to proper fishkeeping. They are there to make $, not give good advice.

Many of us have learned this the hard way.
 

Most reactions

trending

Staff online

Back
Top