We are not actually differing here, but keep in mind I did qualify my comments. Ammonia can kill plants, depending upon the plant species and the level of ammonia. When a new hobbyist takes things at face value and dumps in too much ammonia, with sensitive plants, and the plants die, it is at the least discouraging for them. And those of us who only use, and have only ever used, the live plant "silent" cycle method are always careful to point out that there are some requirements with this method such as enough fast-growing plants for one, that are clearly growing and not dying. There is not the slightest doubt but that a plant silent cycle is the safest and quickest way to set up a new tank. I just think it is better to do one or the other.
I know TwoTankAmin, we have corresponded privately by email for years, and I respect his knowledge and advice. I don't think I am countering it relative to the initial question, since I am only suggesting caution, though it has been a long while since I read the cycling articles.