Geod in the tank???

The April FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Tanked

Fish Herder
Joined
Apr 30, 2003
Messages
1,859
Reaction score
0
Location
Hollywood, Florida, USA
I have a really pretty sliver (solid all the way through and has been polished) of blue geod I would like to put in my tank but before doing so woulf like some feedback. If I boiled it to remove any sediment would it be ok in my tank?
 
If you're certain that the area where it came from has no ecological contamination, (didn't come off a landfill or near a sewage treatment plant, ect) it will be ok. Geodes are formed when water seeps into a pocket of trapped O2 in bedrock, where it deposits disolved solids. The O2 causes the solids to crystalize. Putting a geode in your tank will add to the TDS present, raising pH and hardness. (One geode shouldn't cause a measurable difference though.) The main thing is being sure the geode wasn't chemically or biologically contaminated.
 
my grand father found it in the rockie moutains while hiking some 20 years ago. mine is just a sliver. He cut the geod in slivers and gave 1 to all of his grandchildren after running it through a rock polisher.

thanks for the info harmonic. i will boil it just to be safe though

pardon my lack of knowledge, but what is TDS?
 
Total Dissolved Solids. It's sort of a conglomeration for dKH, gH, pH, conductivity, alkalinity, and buffering ability resulted by the overall mineral content of the wayer. Basically a count of everything that gives the water it's elemental parameters. Your geode will add to these levels. Depending on the current TDS level of your water, you might or might not be able to measure any difference in your elemental (as apposed to biological, i.e. ammonia, trites and trates) parameters. To simplify, the lower your pH, the more effect the geode will have on your water. I can't tell you exactly what the lowest pH you can have with no measurable change would be without knowing the exact molecular make ups of your geode and your water. As a guess, I'd say you wouldn't notice any change unless your current pH is less than 7.5 - If your pH is down in the 6's, I imagine you will detect parameter changes fairly quick.

If you do have pH <7.0, and really want to use your geode, you can, but you'll need to do water changes a little more frequently to combat it's water hardening effect.

FYI, TDS is a measurement used almost exclusively in the saltwater reef side of the hobby, as it is vital to reduce all the water's components to zero, allowing hobbyists to add carefully measured doses of some of those components back into the water so that they do know its exact molecular make up, and adjust accordingly. Very few freshwater fish require this extreme knowledge of water chemistry... discus are the only ones that come to mind right now. As long as you're keeping normal, common tropicals, the only parts of the TDS levels in your water you need to worry about are pH and hardness.

It *is* helpful to have a brief understanding of what TDS means, obviously, just in case some chemistry nut shows up and mentions it. :lol:

That's a cool heirloom to have, btw. Good luck with it. :)
 

Most reactions

trending

Staff online

Back
Top