Can guppies change gender?

biofish

Fishaholic
Pet of the Month!
Joined
Jul 23, 2021
Messages
482
Reaction score
368
Location
California
I was looking it up and was getting mixed results. If it is possible, I’ve personally never seen it happen.

I keep the genders separated and they only ever interact in my breeding tank. Most of my fish have never interacted with the other gender besides their siblings when they were in the growing out tank before they were gendered and separated. And if you haven’t seen my other posts, 90-95% of my guppy fry end up being female (my batch of 31 fry that are a couple months old, only 3 are male. The rest have the triangular anal fin, gravid spot, and bigger bodies).

Is there a certain trigger to switching genders? I’ve heard that gravid spots can’t be used to gender female fry but I’ve personally never witnessed a fry with a gravid spot loosing it.

I’m honestly just curious ❤️❤️❤️
 

Slaphppy7

Mod Squaderator
Staff member
Global Moderator
Joined
Jan 20, 2021
Messages
6,873
Reaction score
5,496
Location
SE Texas
Guppies can't "change" gender, are far as I'm aware of..... @emeraldking can confirm if I'm right or wrong
 

kiko

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Feb 13, 2022
Messages
113
Reaction score
52
Location
Toronto, Canada
no trigger...just genetic defects...they can change gender if they're born hermaphrodites which allows them to "choose" their sex
a fish that also does this as fry would be dwarf pea puffers so if you get 2 baby fry puffers the first male would make the other wannabe male into his "*****" and in turn he'll turn female
but once they choose there's no going back
so if you bought 9 grown females and 3 grown male guppies...you'll see no gender switching at all
also even though people sometimes buy 1 fish and in a few weeks see a few extra in the tank...keep in mind the females can "store" sperm to spawn at a later time
 

Colin_T

Fish Guru
Joined
Jan 26, 2008
Messages
35,140
Reaction score
18,701
Location
Perth, WA
Swordtails can change from female to male if there are no other males around for a long time (6 months or more). I don't think guppies can.

@emeraldking is our livebearer expert and should be able to confirm one way or the other.
 

emeraldking

Moderator
Staff member
Global Moderator
Joined
Sep 13, 2016
Messages
2,634
Reaction score
3,859
Location
NL
Nowadays, it's becoming a taboo to speak of a birth defect when we are speaking of hermaphrodites. But yes, hermaphrodites do occur in ovoviviparous livebearers but not in viviparous livebearers (as far as we know). But in ovoviviparous it's a bit hard to claim that when females change into males should be labeled as hermaphroditism. For there are females that do have male gonads but have a complete female phenotype and there are specimens that have both male and female features already ever since almost the beginning. So yes, there are livebearers that do have both male and female gonads. But in that case, they all will start off as being a female. From what we know is that specimens that seem to be female change into male are coming from an XX, WX, WY combination. And a combination with the Z sex chromosome seems to be making a sex change possible. In normal situations we only know XX as being female and XY as being male. But it's already known that that there are more combinations possible. Which is already a step forward to dive into the sex genetics. Those people who claim that sex change is not possible only believe that there is just an XX or XY combination possible. And that this is just an urban story. So, only male and female. It doesn't only concern fish but also other live forms. They're just lacking knowledge in the sex genetics.
Extern factors can trigger a female to become a male. With the exception of the Xiphophorus genus (where swordtails and platies belong to), it's very rare. But real hermaphrodites in ovoviviparous livebearers are both male and female at the same time and will show as adults real large specimens with an undeveloped gonopodium. Such specimens won't be able to reproduce themselves. And yes, they do show a gravid spot as well, because they've started off as being female. Once a gravid spot is present, it will remain visible. For the gravid spot is just a piece of skin that does have a lower density than other skin parts of the body. But don't confuse them with late males. Late males are initial males from the beginning. And late males never show a real gravid spot.
In swordtails and platies it's already been proven how it's possible that certain phenotypical females can change into male. Depending on wether it has got to do with swordtails or platies, the combination of alleles and sex chromosome combination is key to produce females that can change into male and wether they'll be able to fertilize other females or not. It's already been researched in other ovoviviparous livebearers as well but, they haven't cleared it yet how it actually works in other ovoviviparous livebearers. But they've observed that those sex changes do occur. And also with those other livebearers that had a sex change, started off as being female.
The story about swordtails and platies changing sex has already been mentioned by me. But eventhough both species are in the same genus, the sex change takes place in a different way in both species. Because sex change happens differently in swordtails in comparison to platies, researchers think that it's possible that sex change in other ovoviviparous livebearers could also differ. It's also a theory of researches that this phenomenon has got to with keeping the population going. And that it's probably a way of how Mother Nature works to let a species survive. It's not an uncommon thing. It's known that it does also happen in other living species on earth.
I also have to mention that all that's been mentioned overhere, wild species have been used and not fancy species for this research. This is why some fancy platy strains and fancy swordtail strains have a sex change situation that should fit the other species. For most nowadays fancy platy strains and fancy swordtail strains are results of crossing between those two species. Which makes a sex change in fancy platies and fancy swordtails doubtful wether it happened by a certain allele combination or a specific sex chromosome combination.

And again, I'd like to refer to a socalled pseudo gravid spot. A pseudo gravid spot only appears in certain male livebearer species. Most known are male platies. But there are also other livebearer species that can show this phenomenon. But such a pseudo gravid spot has got the same density like other skin parts. And such a pseudo gravid spot is a matter of having more melanophores developing on the same spot where a female has got her gravis pot. But once a pseudo gravid spot appears, it will never fade. Most of the time such a pseudo gravid spot in platies will occur when they're close to adulthood.

And the story about old females show male features....which features are shown in the finnage of the old female... Well, that has got to do with the MSX genes. Just like humans older female ovoviviparous livebearers, can stop being reproductive. When that happens, a hormonal change takes place which triggers the activity of the MSX genes in a higher activity. This results in male features in finnage (larger and/or elongated fins). This concerns all fins possible. But mostly seen in dorsal, caudal and anal fin. For the MSX genes are responsible for the morphological change in finnage. But it will remain a female specimen and has got nothing to do with turning into male.

But to answer the question: Can female guppies change into males? The answer will be: That's possible. But again, very rare...
 

Most reactions

trending

Staff online

Top