Ammonia

April FOTM Photo Contest Starts Now!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to enter! 🏆

I studied 5 years on freshwater tanks and stuff before I bought my fish and stuff. My filter sucks and I know that now. The compatibility between my fish is intermediate. All my fish are like 2 months old and mad young. Im upgrading really soon anyway so a 62 Galloon.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I studied 5 years on freshwater tanks and stuff before I bought my fish and stuff. My filter sucks and I know that now. The compatibility between my fish is intermediate. All my fish are like 2 months old and mad young. Im upgrading really soon anyway so a 62 Galloon.

I guess I always hope people can learn, so I persist. Taking one sentence, "The compatibility between my fish is intermediate" again shows your lack of knowledge on the subject. Fish interaction is very complex, and I am sorry, but you certainly do not have any idea as to what is happening with these fish in this environment. Some irreversible damage has already been done, more will occur. That is just how science works when you try to counter what is programmed into the species' DNA. What about the pheromones and allomones being released, and read? The stress, that causes 95% of all fish disease? The only reason physical attacks have not occurred--if you are truthful that they haven't been seen by you though that doesn't mean they are not occurring--is that the small confines are seriously impacting the fish's physiology and metabolism. The fish may simply waste away, or at some point they might fight back without warning. Fish biology is a very complex subject. All of us are well served to listen to those who know.
 
Your into deep rn. Smh. Its not as serious as u make it sound. All my fish are gonna live period. I haven’t killed a fish once period. Like chill u act like uk what’s going on in my tank by me just saying what fish I have and what size. That’s not how it works. U do u and ill do me and everything will be fine. Bye.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
@jredouard25

I'm afraid to say Byron is right, and you are wrong.

Fish have evolved to live in certain ways, in certain kinds of water, and to have certain patterns of behaviour. There is no way of changing this. It is perfectly possible to know what kinds of problems are going to arise, if an experienced aquarist knows what fish species are present. Tiger barbs will always behave like tiger barbs, bettas will always behave like bettas, and African cichlids will always be very aggressive. That IS how it works.

The fish you have are not compatible, and they will never live happy or healthy lives together, even in a larger tank.

Just at the very basic level, you have fish that need soft, acidic water (the corydoras, betta and gourami), and fish that need it hard and alkaline (the African cichlids). Even completely leaving aside the behaviour issues, there is no way you can keep those fish healthy in the same tank, it's just not possible.

Turning to the behavioural issues now, you do have multiple, serious problems, whatever you might think. Tiger barbs should never, ever, be kept with long finned fish like bettas. Bettas and gouramis should never be kept together, as they're very closely related and will compete for territory. African cichlids should, always and only, be in specialist Rift Valley set ups. They need such specific water conditions, and have such high aggression levels, that they cannot be mixed with other fish.

You might also run into huge problems with your corydoras. As you cichlids get bigger, they're very likely to try and eat the cories. Unfortunately, corydoras have a spine on their gill covers that means they will get stuck in the cichlid's throat. You will lose both fish, if that happens, as there is no way of separating the two.

We're not saying these things because we're showing off, or we want to have a go at people. We say them because we care about the welfare of the fish, nothing else.

You are free to do exactly as you wish; they're your fish, your responsibility, and no-one is coming to come around to your house and force you to separate them.

But do, please, acknowledge that there are people who have more experience than you. Just as an example, I've been keeping fish for over 40 years, and have kept, and bred, every fish on your list, but I still listen to the experts, and know that I still have things to learn.

Dismissing someone's advice because you think they're taking things too seriously, or think you know best, is not the way to become a better fishkeeper, which is what we should all be aiming for.
 
@jredouard25

I'm afraid to say Byron is right, and you are wrong.

Fish have evolved to live in certain ways, in certain kinds of water, and to have certain patterns of behaviour. There is no way of changing this. It is perfectly possible to know what kinds of problems are going to arise, if an experienced aquarist knows what fish species are present. Tiger barbs will always behave like tiger barbs, bettas will always behave like bettas, and African cichlids will always be very aggressive. That IS how it works.

The fish you have are not compatible, and they will never live happy or healthy lives together, even in a larger tank.

Just at the very basic level, you have fish that need soft, acidic water (the corydoras, betta and gourami), and fish that need it hard and alkaline (the African cichlids). Even completely leaving aside the behaviour issues, there is no way you can keep those fish healthy in the same tank, it's just not possible.

Turning to the behavioural issues now, you do have multiple, serious problems, whatever you might think. Tiger barbs should never, ever, be kept with long finned fish like bettas. Bettas and gouramis should never be kept together, as they're very closely related and will compete for territory. African cichlids should, always and only, be in specialist Rift Valley set ups. They need such specific water conditions, and have such high aggression levels, that they cannot be mixed with other fish.

You might also run into huge problems with your corydoras. As you cichlids get bigger, they're very likely to try and eat the cories. Unfortunately, corydoras have a spine on their gill covers that means they will get stuck in the cichlid's throat. You will lose both fish, if that happens, as there is no way of separating the two.

We're not saying these things because we're showing off, or we want to have a go at people. We say them because we care about the welfare of the fish, nothing else.

You are free to do exactly as you wish; they're your fish, your responsibility, and no-one is coming to come around to your house and force you to separate them.

But do, please, acknowledge that there are people who have more experience than you. Just as an example, I've been keeping fish for over 40 years, and have kept, and bred, every fish on your list, but I still listen to the experts, and know that I still have things to learn.

Dismissing someone's advice because you think they're taking things too seriously, or think you know best, is not the way to become a better fishkeeper, which is what we should all be aiming for.

Ok...My gourami and betta nvr have fought and my tiger barbs are fine. I’ll trade in the cichlids then ig.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
@jredouard25

I'm afraid to say Byron is right, and you are wrong.

Fish have evolved to live in certain ways, in certain kinds of water, and to have certain patterns of behaviour. There is no way of changing this. It is perfectly possible to know what kinds of problems are going to arise, if an experienced aquarist knows what fish species are present. Tiger barbs will always behave like tiger barbs, bettas will always behave like bettas, and African cichlids will always be very aggressive. That IS how it works.

The fish you have are not compatible, and they will never live happy or healthy lives together, even in a larger tank.

Just at the very basic level, you have fish that need soft, acidic water (the corydoras, betta and gourami), and fish that need it hard and alkaline (the African cichlids). Even completely leaving aside the behaviour issues, there is no way you can keep those fish healthy in the same tank, it's just not possible.

Turning to the behavioural issues now, you do have multiple, serious problems, whatever you might think. Tiger barbs should never, ever, be kept with long finned fish like bettas. Bettas and gouramis should never be kept together, as they're very closely related and will compete for territory. African cichlids should, always and only, be in specialist Rift Valley set ups. They need such specific water conditions, and have such high aggression levels, that they cannot be mixed with other fish.

You might also run into huge problems with your corydoras. As you cichlids get bigger, they're very likely to try and eat the cories. Unfortunately, corydoras have a spine on their gill covers that means they will get stuck in the cichlid's throat. You will lose both fish, if that happens, as there is no way of separating the two.

We're not saying these things because we're showing off, or we want to have a go at people. We say them because we care about the welfare of the fish, nothing else.

You are free to do exactly as you wish; they're your fish, your responsibility, and no-one is coming to come around to your house and force you to separate them.

But do, please, acknowledge that there are people who have more experience than you. Just as an example, I've been keeping fish for over 40 years, and have kept, and bred, every fish on your list, but I still listen to the experts, and know that I still have things to learn.

Dismissing someone's advice because you think they're taking things too seriously, or think you know best, is not the way to become a better fishkeeper, which is what we should all be aiming for.

My betta is a female and so are all my other fish.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
@jredouard25

I'm afraid to say Byron is right, and you are wrong.

Fish have evolved to live in certain ways, in certain kinds of water, and to have certain patterns of behaviour. There is no way of changing this. It is perfectly possible to know what kinds of problems are going to arise, if an experienced aquarist knows what fish species are present. Tiger barbs will always behave like tiger barbs, bettas will always behave like bettas, and African cichlids will always be very aggressive. That IS how it works.

The fish you have are not compatible, and they will never live happy or healthy lives together, even in a larger tank.

Just at the very basic level, you have fish that need soft, acidic water (the corydoras, betta and gourami), and fish that need it hard and alkaline (the African cichlids). Even completely leaving aside the behaviour issues, there is no way you can keep those fish healthy in the same tank, it's just not possible.

Turning to the behavioural issues now, you do have multiple, serious problems, whatever you might think. Tiger barbs should never, ever, be kept with long finned fish like bettas. Bettas and gouramis should never be kept together, as they're very closely related and will compete for territory. African cichlids should, always and only, be in specialist Rift Valley set ups. They need such specific water conditions, and have such high aggression levels, that they cannot be mixed with other fish.

You might also run into huge problems with your corydoras. As you cichlids get bigger, they're very likely to try and eat the cories. Unfortunately, corydoras have a spine on their gill covers that means they will get stuck in the cichlid's throat. You will lose both fish, if that happens, as there is no way of separating the two.

We're not saying these things because we're showing off, or we want to have a go at people. We say them because we care about the welfare of the fish, nothing else.

You are free to do exactly as you wish; they're your fish, your responsibility, and no-one is coming to come around to your house and force you to separate them.

But do, please, acknowledge that there are people who have more experience than you. Just as an example, I've been keeping fish for over 40 years, and have kept, and bred, every fish on your list, but I still listen to the experts, and know that I still have things to learn.

Dismissing someone's advice because you think they're taking things too seriously, or think you know best, is not the way to become a better fishkeeper, which is what we should all be aiming for.

African cichlids dont need a hard alkaline. There from lake Malawi. Search it. They do good in 7.2-8.5 ph ty.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
pH is not hardness.

What is the hardness of your tank?
 
African cichlids dont need a hard alkaline. There from lake Malawi. Search it. They do good in 7.2-8.5 ph ty.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Buddy, I don't want to argue with you, but I'm well acquainted with Rift Valley cichlids; I kept and bred mbuna, other Lake Malawis and Tanganikans for many years.

They evolved in hard alkaline water, and will not live long, or be healthy, if the water is too soft and acidic. You can disagree all you like, but I'm sorry, that won't change the facts.

As I've said, these are your fish, we can't do a single thing to change how you're keeping them, but you should really educate yourself on their proper care.
 
Buddy, I don't want to argue with you, but I'm well acquainted with Rift Valley cichlids; I kept and bred mbuna, other Lake Malawis and Tanganikans for many years.

They evolved in hard alkaline water, and will not live long, or be healthy, if the water is too soft and acidic. You can disagree all you like, but I'm sorry, that won't change the facts.

As I've said, these are your fish, we can't do a single thing to change how you're keeping them, but you should really educate yourself on their proper care.

U want them then. I’ll give u the bumblebee one for $5.50


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Mate, first of all, I don't kept African cichlids anymore, as I live in a soft water area. I'm also, unfortunately, in the UK.
 
Mate, first of all, I don't kept African cichlids anymore, as I live in a soft water area. I'm also, unfortunately, in the UK.

What about African Cichlids. Do they require hard alkaline and water.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Mate, first of all, I don't kept African cichlids anymore, as I live in a soft water area. I'm also, unfortunately, in the UK.

8486d3c6f485fe88fb134ca29dfca182.png



i got this one.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Most reactions

Back
Top