What other fish should NOT be kept with these?

Just need to plan my stocking

Thanks

No guppies, gouramis, tiger barbs, goldfish, shark, mostly its better to keep them alone.

not very many fish are ok with them.
but are we talking male or female?

I have a Kuhli Loach with mine. You could also do snails or a dwarf frog.

It's going to depend on if it's a male or female though. You have get away with more if it's a female.

It will be a male. Thanks for info but one more question, out of the fish named what is the general reason not to keep them with a male siamese fighting fish?

More for my own knowledge than anything else. Thanks

They might nip the fin and kill each o ther. For guppies they think that it is another male and for the other fish they are fin nippers.

For fish with long fins, the betta may see them as a threat and attack them. Things like guppies fit in this catagory.

For things like tiger barbs, they're know fin nippers and will make quick work of a betta's fins.

Guppies because they will look at their lovely long tails and in the bettas head they see another betta, not a guppy.

Tetras, barbs and sharks are nippy and therefore your betta may well end up with no fins left.

Gouramis because they inhabit the same are of the tank and are territorial, so they and the betta would fight.

With every betta it's a hit and miss as some will be more docile than others. Your best bet is non-nippy, non-brightly coloured/fast moving fish. Most bottom dwellers are OK, but have somewhere spare to put the betta just in case.

I have mine with zebra danios, silver hatchets and a ruby tailed shark. They all get on fine, no probs. In fact, the SFF and shark share the same cave a lot of the time and seem quite happy with each other.

Thanks for all the info people. Appreciate it. i think my plan of action now then is to eventually transfer my fish from the small tank (30l) to the new big tank(120l), when ready, then if i choose to get SFF i'll use the small tank for it with a few little friendly fish that they won't fight with.

I'll see though for now, given me a lot to ponder. Thanks

I had 2 cory cats with my betta and he removed too much of the fins of one and nipped the fins off the other. I moved them to the other tank but they still died. Now all that is in the tank with him is a red claw crab. They seem to avoid each other. I didn't see any fighting with the cories either though.

I had a male fighter fish when i first set up my tank and had no problems with him and other fish in the tank. unfortunatley he died and i replaced him with another who was far more aggressive and attacked every other fish in the tank. he stayed with me for about 2 days before i rehomed him in a friends tank and with bigger fish. and to this day he has caused no problems and is still alive.

I think they are really good looking fish but i would never put another in my tank.

Such good looking fish, this is what i plan on having as soon as i can.

What beauties they are http://www.cs.washington.edu/homes/lachesi...erFishMedly.bmp I saw a red one today which I plan to get, but will it harm my goldfish?

I had a gorgeous red betta...for a few hours...until my albino shark stripped him bare

Well I have a male betta in my community tank...and he gets on fine with all the fish in there....they do not bother him at all...I have tetra, mollies, golden barbs..cory's to name a few...the only ones he does not seem to like are the 2 orange mollies and the orange platy think he just doesn't like the colour orange.... ....he flares at them all the time and they seem wary of him, but apart from that he seems very happy in there...infact I would go as far to say...he is the boss....first there at feeding time, and does not let anyone get in the way of his grub...he is great and one of my favourite fish that I have....I have named him billy....as in billy no mates....lol....!

This post has been edited by debbie888: May 19 2008, 08:13 PM

not a good idea as first, bettas/siamese fighting fish are tropical and goldfish are coldwater.
goldfish require heavily filtered tanks and fighters prefer still/little wter movement caused by filters.
goldfish produce a lot of waste which will quickly polute the water.

if you really want one, get a small tank 2-5 gallons is ideal and keep a lone male

anybody know how endlers get on with betta's?

i keep mine with 3 cherry shrimp and to be honest lastnight i saw one of them swam after him across the tank,crash into him when he stopped and all my betta did was swim off 2 nother part of the tank

i've heard there is a high chance betta's will eat shrimp but mine gets bullied by them lol

I keep my male betta with swordtails mollies and tetras and they all get along fine but i am moving him to his own tank cause i think he is doing a bit of bullying.

Part of me wishes i had a female cause i think you can keep females in the same tank?

dem0nz, I do not keep my endlrrs with my betta because I want the fry from their breeding and he would be population control plus. As far as keeping adult endlers with a betta they should be fine together. Most bettas are not as aggressive as people would have you believe but they do like small live food.

This post has been edited by OldMan47: May 20 2008, 11:25 PM